Caught By Friend’s Little Sister And Her Friends

[Themarble]

The chapter just came out today and I feel like I already need more! I am loving the situations Peter is out in, Peter's luck has pushed him this far! I wonder how much further the girls can push him?

[Jeepman89]

The girls are having way too much fun to stop now. I'm sure Margerie and Amelia will have more ideas of their own as well.

[nebnyc]

Love Peter’s involvement at another birthday party for much younger girls! The spanking by Kate & all the girls checking out his taint in the crab walk position were highlights. They all seemed to have felt & explored every inch of him & Dean. Looking forward for more ways the girls can have fun with their 17 year old plaything. Dean & Jon, also nude, seem just as interested in seeing the girls controlling the much older & bigger Peter.

[NudeBaG]

Caught By Friend's Little Sister Part 7

As if on queue, the doorbell rang.
The younger girls giggled excitedly.
Judy motioned for everyone to stay and be quiet.
The girls sitting on the couch looked back at us in anticipation.
Judy and Kate headed to the door.
We heard the door open.
“Hey, Margerie?”
“Judy? I’m guessing?”
“Nice to meet you!”
“Nice to meet you too!”
“Hi Kate!”
“Hi Amelia!”
“Is Peter really here?” Margerie asked.
“Yup! And 2 other boys!” Judy said.
“Where?” Margerie asked sharply.
“Hmhmhm! This way!” Judy and Kate lead Amelia and Margerie down the hall.
As we heard the footsteps getting closer, my heart and cock began throbbing!
The girls looked at us lined up behind the couch as the girls sat on and in front of it.
Then their eyes drifted to the mirror behind us.
“Yay! Look Margerie! They’re really naked!” Amelia pointed and cheered.
Margerie looked to the mirror and burst out laughing.
“Oh my Gosh! Amelia, don’t look! Don’t those boys know we can see their butts?!” Margerie teased.
I felt myself blush, even though I knew what was about to happen.
“Hey! Kate!” Amelia pointed. “Can I see them ALL Naked?”
Kate was laughing too hard to answer.
“Of course! That’s what you’re here for!” Judy cheered.
“Who do you wan’t to see first, Amelia?!” Cindy asked.
This new little girl stood on the other side of the couch.
Kate calmed down and stepped next to her.
“They’re all different, too!” She added.
“Huh?” Amelia asked.
Kate smiled at us.
“Yeah! Peter has a really BIG one!” Kate pointed to Peter.
Margerie stood on her tip toes to try and see over the back of the couch.
Even though she was Peter’s age, an older teen, she was still glancing at Jon and I.
“Amelia! We’ll be in the same school as Dean and Jon someday! Do you want to see one of them first?!” Margerie asked.
Amelia’s face lit up.
She looked at me, then at Jon.
“Oh no! No no no no!” Jon pulled away from the couch a bit as he whispered to himself.
“That one!” Amelia pointed at Jon.
“Oooooo! Amelia! You wanna see Jon’s weiner first?!” Kate gasped.
“Yeah! I see him the most! Anytime I come over to play! I wanna see HIS weiner! Hehehehe!” Amelia laughed.
Milli stepped around behind the couch to stand next to Jon.
“M-Milli! No! Wait!” Jon begged as Milli tugged on his arm.
“Milli! Wait!” Judy yelled.
“Milli! Please!” Jon begged as
Milli tried to pull Jon from behind the couch, but she relented when Judy yelled.
Jon retreated back.
There were a few giggles, but neither Amelia nor Margerie had seen.
Milli stepped back next to Judy, looking slightly confused.
“I just thought of a new game!” Judy looked around. “But I think Amelia or Margerie might be the only ones who can play this one.”
The girls excitedly looked at Amelia.
“Oh?” Margerie looked surprised.
She stepped next to her little sister.
Judy spun around.
She looked at all the girls.
“What kinda game?” Kate asked. “And why only them?!” She looked upset.
“It’s just a quick guessing game!” Judy said.
She winked at Kate and gave the ‘Okay’ sign.
Kate still looked apprehensive, but was willing to see what happened next.
“Fiiiiiiiiiiirst,” Judy pulled the ribbons from 9 year old Kelly’s hair.
“Hey!” Kelly yelped, grabbing her unravelling pigtails
“Sorry! Can I borrow these?” Judy asked the girl sweetly, and with a wink.
Young Kelly realized her hair ribbons must play a part in the night’s events.
“Yeah! Sure!” Kelly agreed with a grin.
Kelly untied her hair ribbons and handed them to Judy, who turned and handed one to Margerie, then stepped behind Amelia.
“We’re gonna use these as blindfolds!” Judy explained.
She wrapped it around Amelia’s eyes.
“Hold still, Amelia!” Judy instructed.
She gently, but snuggly tugged the ribbon around Amelia’s head, blinding her eyes.
She looked at Margerie.
“Oh! Okay?” Margerie glanced at us boys one more time and smiled before wrapping the ribbon around her eyes.
With both Margerie and Amelia blindfolded, Judy walked around them, positioning them side by side in the middle of the livingroom.
“Okay! We’re now gonna put each boy in front of you and let you feel their cocks!” Judy explained.
All the girls giggled.
“After that, we’ll unblindfold you, and you’ll match each cock with a number: 1, 2 or 3!”
Margerie and Amelia giggled excitedly.
“Okay!” Judy motioned for me to step up first.
I walked around the couch as the girls giggled, taking the opportunity to ogle my nudity again.
I was still sporting an erection too!
I stood in front of Margerie first.
She was really pretty, and talker than me by a few inches!
“Boy 1 is in front of you now, Margerie.” Judy informed her.
Judy brought Margerie’s hand to my penis!
I shuttered at her touch!
“Oh! Oooooo! Already stiff? Haha!” Margerie moved her fingers along my shaft to my sparce pubes.
“Hmmm.” She then moved her fingers slowly up my shaft to the head!
With her other hand, she gently felt my balls!
My penis began twitching!
“Nice and smooth. Hmhm!” She chuckled.
God!
Her gentle, exploratory handling felt amazing, but also strangely ‘clinical’.
She wrapped her hand around my shaft and gave a squeeze before letting go.
“And stiff! Haha!” She added.
“Okay, Margerie. Now for boy number 2!” Judy gestured for Jon to step up next.
The girls burst into giggles as Milli walked Jon to Margerie, holding him by the cuffs.
Jon’s penis was sticking straight out in it’s fully erect state, keeping the girls giggling constantly.
Margerie reached forward, but ended up just swiping her hand, missing Jon’s penis completely.
Everyone giggled.
“A little closer, Margerie. Hang on.” Mili pushed Jon forward a bit as Margerie brought her fingers up to meet Jon’s genitals.
“Oh!” Margerie’s fingers engulfed Jon’s little penis!
Jon closed his eyes tight.
“Oh! Oh, well- Hmhm!” Margerie chuckled as she cupped her hand over Jon’s full package!
“Hmmmmm.” Margerie pursed her lips, trying not to laugh.
She pulled her hands back as Peter stepped up and Jon moved to the side.
Peter looked nervous, but his massive penis was twitching and sticking out!
A few girls giggled, but Judy immediately ‘shushed’ them.
“Okay! Boy #3 is in front of you now!” Judy smiled.
Everyone watched silently as Margerie extended her hand.
Margerie’s fingers made contact with Peter’s groin first, then slid slowly along the side of his penis!
Margerie slowly ran her fingers all the way down Peter’s shaft to the head of his penis!
“Oh! Oh my god! Well….!” Margerie gasped. “I think I know who this is! Hmhmhm!”
Margerie gripped Peter’s penis in her hand.
She gave a couple strokes!
“Okay! Okay!” Judy shook her head, pulling Margerie back next to Amelia.
Judy stood behind Amelia, placing her hands on her shoulders.
Amelia was giggling excitedly.
“Here comes boy number one!” Judy nodded at me.
I stepped forward.
I was trembling!
Judy moved Amelia’s hand to my penis.
God!
I was SO hard!
“Oooo!” Amelia cood as her delicate fingers brushed over the smooth head of my penis!
She slid her fingers down to wrap around my shaft.
I trembled and felt my penis tense up!
Oh god!
No!
“Hehehehe!” Amelia squeezed my penis!
She gave me 2 strokes before letting go!
“Okay, Amelia! Here’s Boy number 2!” Judy nodded at Jon.
Milli pushed Jon forward.
Jon just clenched his eyes shut.
Amelia waved her hand back and forth, feeling low in the area in front of her.
“Hehehe! A little further, Amelia!” Kate chirped.
“Hehehe! Where is-“ Amelia froze as her fingers landed on Jon’s belly.
“Oh! Here we go! Haha!” Amelia ran her fingers down and all over Jon’s tummy before resting on the base of his penis.
“Oh!” She gasped and gently pinched Jon’s penis from base to head!
“Hmmmm.” She seemed confused.
She moved her hand back down to his little balls.
“Hehehe! This is fun!” Amelia giggled, along with everyone else.
“Okay!” Judy ushered Amelia to stand in front of Peter.
“And now for Boy Number 3!” Judy lifted Amelia’s hand to Peter’s penis.
Amelia gasped as she wrapped her fingers around Peter’s semi-erect penis!
Amelia lifted her other hand and began feeling Peter’s penis with BOTH hands!
She moved one to his scrotum.
“Oh! OH! Hehehehe!” Amelia giggled. “This boy has BIG BALLS!”
Everyone laughed as Judy pulled Amelia back next to Margerie.
Peter, me and Jon stepped back behind the couch.
The girls were going crazy with laughter, trying not to give anything away.
Peter actually had to slouch so that his erect penis would be completely hidden behind the couch.
“Okay! Margerie and Amelia! Take off your blind f-“ Judy was cut off as Milli darted behind the couch with us boys.
“Wait!” Milli yelped as she stepped between us.
She grabbed Peter’s hips and moved him all the way to the end, squeezing his butt!
She then swapped Jon and I.
The order before had been a simple 1, 2 and 3. Now, it was 3, 1 and 2.
I assume she did this to confuse Margerie and Amelia.
“Okay! Margerie and Amelia!” Judy paused and looked at Milli, then looked at us guys.
All 3 of us kept our crotches pressed against the back of the couch.
“Take off your blind folds!” Judy cheered.
Amelia practically ripped her eye covering off.
Margerie simply untied hers, laughing.
“Okay, which boy had the ‘biggest’ cock?” Judy asked.
Everyone giggled excitedly.
Both Margerie and Amelia pointed to Peter.
“Which boy?” Judy asked, acting unsure.
Margerie burst put laughing.
“Peter! He’s the oldest!” Amelia cheered and pointed.
“Which number?” Judy asked.
“3! Boy number 3!” Amelia hopped excitedly.
“Okay!” Judy shrugged. “Boy 3! Let’s see that cock!”
Milli grabbed Jon’s cuffed arms behind his back.
“N-No!” Jon gasped as Milli pulled him out to face Amelia and Margerie.
Both girls reacted in shock.
They stared, wide eyed at Jon’s smooth body.
“Oh! Hmhm!” Margerie chuckled.
“Oooooooooh!” Amelia lit up seeing Jon’s stiff little penis!
Milli knelt next to Jon’s hip.
“Hmmm! I don’t think you guessed right.” Milli teased.
“Margerie, Amelia- this is my big brother Jon’s cock!” Kate chirped.
She then reached down and pinched Jon’s penis, which made everyone gasp.
“K-Kate!” Jon gasped.
“It gets stiff, but doesn’t change that much.” Kate explained.
Jon looked like he wanted to die.
He was pale, but his little penis was as hard as ever!
Margerie and Amelia were giggling like crazy, staring at Jon’s nudity.
Margerie stepped to Jon.
She extended her hand.
“Oh my god!” Margerie smiled. “It’s nice to meet you!” She added.
There was an awkward pause.
“Uh-um-“ Jon stammered.
“Oh! Sorry, Margerie!” Milli said. “Jon has been naughty, so we needed to cuff him.” Cindy explained.
“Oh! Um,” Margerie looked at her hand.
There was another brief pause, then Margerie smiled.
She reached forward and held Jon’s balls on her finger tips!
“Oh my gosh! Look at that little stiffy!” Margerie beamed.
“Ah! Um-“ Jon gasped.
Margerie then ran her fingers down Jon’s short shaft!
“So cute!” She beamed.
Little Amelia looked at Jon’s penis then looked back up at him.
“Your weiner is stiff, but it’s tiny! Haha!” Amelia laughed.
“Well,” Judy spoke. “I don’t think you guessed the right boy.”
The girls ‘Boo’d’ but also giggled excitedly.
“Okay! Boy 2 is illiminated!” Judy said.
Milli took Jon by the cuffs and ushered him to the couch, where Allison and Kelly took over teasing him.
“Okay, Amelia, Margerie. Which boy has the biggest cock? Boy 1? Or Boy 3?” Judy gestured at Peter and I.
Margerie and Amelia were giggling excitedly.
With Jon eliminated, it was obvious who Boy 1 and Boy 3 were, but the game must continue.
Margerie whispered in Amelia’s ear.
Amelia lit up and looked at me, beaming.
“I think Boy 1 has the biggest cock! Hehehe!” Amelia pointed at Peter.
“Okay!” Judy motioned for either Peter or I to step around the couch next.
But Boy 1 wasn’t Peter.
I sighed deeply and put my hands on the back of my head.
Amelia and Margerie looked at me in surprise.
I stepped around the couch and the girls burst into giggles.
I looked down.
My penis was rock hard and sticking straight up!
“Oh! Oh wow!” Margerie seemed surprised.
“Hehehehe! Oh my god!” Amelia hopped up and down excitedly.
Judy and Milli were also grinning.
I stepped up to the older teen and her young sister.
“This is Dean!” Kate beamed, eyeing me up and down.
Amelia stood directly in front of me, staring at my erect penis.
“Yay! Margerie, look!” Amelia pointed, her finger hovering about 4 inches from my throbbing penis!
“Oooooo! Hmhmhm!” Margerie chuckled.
Remembering how Margerie went to shake Jon’s hand, I quickly held my hand out.
Both Margerie and Amelia paused, looking at my hand.
“I don’t think your hand is what we want to shake. Hmhm!” Margerie teased.
“Go ahead, Amelia!” Kate chirped.
“Grab his cock!” Cindy added.
I sighed and put my hands on the back of my head again.
Amelia, still with her hand pointing at my penis, decided to go ahead with the suggestion.
Amelia reached forward the rest of the way and wrapped her petite hand around my penis!
My whole body trembled.
Amelia’s mouth and eyes opened wide.
“Wow!” Amelia sighed as she gripped my cock!
I could feel it pulsing in her hand!
She then turned to Margerie. “He’s got a really stiff weiner! Hahaha!” She laughed.
The girls all giggled.
Amelia let go of my penis.
Margerie stepped forward.
She looked down at me.
She then knelt down to examine my genitals.
“Oooooo!” She cood, blowing a jet of air over my penis!
“Ahhhhh-ah ha ha!” I trembled.
“Hahaha! Oh my god! Your weiner IS stiff! Haha!” Margerie laughed.
She stood up.
I looked at her.
She moved her hand to my penis.
An older teen girl was touching my penis!
“Ah! Um, uh-!” I gasped.
I felt Margerie’s fingers gently explore my penis!
She wrapped her hand around my shaft and gave one long, slow stroke!
I unconsciously thrust my hips a bit.
Margerie moved her hand away and looked down.
I stopped thrusting, but my penis kept twitching.
“How old are you?” She asked.
“Th-13?” I stammered.
“Hmmm. Hmhm!” Margerie chuckled.
“13. That’s only 2 years older than me!” Amelia chirped.
Everyone laughed.
Amelia looked at Jon.
“How old are you?” She asked.
“12.” Jon said timidly.
Amelia smiled at his stiff little penis.
“Hahaha! Wow! You’re only a year younger, and your cock is THAT tiny?! That’s funny!” Amelia teased.
Jon looked like he was going to cry.
“Awww! Don’t be mean!” Milli said.
She caressed Jon’s shoulder.
Margerie was still smiling at my penis.
Amelia looked at Peter behind the couch.
“Hehehe! Now we get to see YOU naked again!” She pointed.
Peter sighed as everyone laughed.
“Go ahead, Peter! You’re up! Hmhm!” Judy cheered.
Peter put his hands on the back of his head and stepped around the couch.
Everyone was silent as Peter stepped out to stand in front of Margerie and Amelia.
Both Margerie and Amelia’s eyes wen’t wide.
Even I had to gasp.
Peter had gone flaccid, but his massive penis and balls were still impressive.
His penis flopped slightly from side to side as he walked.
Even though he was limp, it still looked huge!
“Oh! Peter!” Margerie smiled wide.
Amelia lit up, but was quick to point out the obvious.
“Peter! Your wiener looks different!” She pointed.
Peter kept his hands behind his head, but did look a little flustered.
Margerie was quick to step up this time.
“Peter Bates! You have the nerve to be naked in front of all these girls, and NOT have a stiffy?!” Margerie taunted.
Margerie looked around at the excited and expectant girls, then, before anyone else could make a move, she reached down and gripped Peter’s penis!
“Oh! God! M-Margerie?” Peter gasped.
He looked nervous.
Margerie also looked shocked as she held Peter’s big floppy cock in her hand.
“Hmhmhmhm!” Margerie chuckled.
“I’ve wanted to do this for a LONG time!” Margerie then slid her hand to the base of Peter’s cock.
She then began swinging it around in a circle!
The soft ‘thwap’ as the head of his cock brushed against his abs made everyone laugh.
“Hahaha! Oh my god! Hahaha!” Margerie was laughing hard as she swung Peter’s cock around.
“Oh!” Margerie gasped and looked down.
She kept holding Peter’s penis at the base, but stepped to the side.
Everyone watched as Peter’s penis sprang to life!
Peter thrust his hips forward and closed his eyes.
His penis rose to stick straight out, then continued on to arch upward slightly!
The girls went crazy!
“Oh my god! Peter Bates!” Margerie gasped.
“Hahaha! Yay! Peter’s cock is big and stiff!” Amelia cheered.
All the girls laughed, hearing little Amelia use the word ‘cock’.
Judy stepped up on the ottoman again.
She looked around the room as the girls excitedly darted around, weaving in between the 3 of us, getting close and touching us everywhere!
“Okay!” Judy clapped her hands, getting everyone’s attention.
“First of all, I’d like to wish Kate here a VERY Happy Birthday!” Judy clapped, triggering everyone else to break into applause.
“From what Cindy told me, you girls have already had a TON of fun, right?”
All the girls cheered again.
Margerie actually stepped up next to Judy and raised her hand.
“Oh! Yes, Margerie?” Judy asked.
Margerie looked around at all the little girls.
“I just want to make sure, is everyone okay with the naked boys?” She asked.
There was a deafening and unanimous “Yes!” from all the little girls.
Margerie just raised her hands and nodded.
“Okay! Okay! I just wanted to be sure.” She stepped back over to Peter.
Judy spoke again.
“Now that we know we all like the naked boys-“ She paused for giggles from the girls. “-I think it’s time for more games!”
Everyone cheered.
Everyone except for Peter, Jon and I.
“What game?!” Kate chirped excitedly.
“It’s one I just came up with!” Judy smiled.
All the girls cood with excitement.
“Oooo! What kind of game?!” 11 year old Eva chirped from beside me.
“Yeah! If Cindy came up with those other games, Judy must have even BETTER games!” 11 year old Amber chymed from my other side.
Everyone waited for Judy to explain the next game.
Judy looked at us boys-lined up and still surrounded by girls.
“It’s more of a game…” Judy looked at Peter, Jon and I. “…for the boys!” Judy smiled at us boys.
I made eye contact with her.
Judy winked at me!
Half the girls cood, but the other half looked as confused as us boys.
“The next game will be…” Judy cupped her hands around her mouth like a megaphone. “…a guessing game!”

[Jeepman89]

Another amazing chapter, NudeBaG! Love the blindfolded guessing game and I look forward to the next game Judy has in mind for the naked boys.