The Binding Bet
Chapter 1: Skin and Ink
The first thing you should know about me is that my best friend sold me out for a pair of limited-edition Manolo Blahniks.
Sarah Cartwright and I had been inseparable since we were six years old when she pushed me off the swing set at Wellington Prep's kindergarten playground and then offered me her favorite hair ribbon as a peace offering. That was Sarah in a nutshell - she'd stab you in the back, then charm you with the knife still sticking out between your ribs.
Tonight, as I lay sprawled across my canopy bed staring at the water stains on the ceiling (even our fifteen-room manor had leaks), I could hear Sarah's laughter floating up from the garden below. She was probably lounging by the pool with Ethan and the twins, sipping the champagne Mrs. Whitmore didn't know they'd stolen from the cellar. I should have been down there with them. Would have been, if not for The Argument.
"Annabel Hamilton, you are not leaving this house dressed like a common streetwalker!"
Mother's voice still rang in my ears three hours later. Never mind that the "revealing outfit" in question was a perfectly modest knit sweater from Bergdorf's - it showed a sliver of midriff when I raised my arms, and that was enough to send the Hamilton household into lockdown.
I reached for my journal, the embossed leather cover worn smooth from years of use. This particular volume held everything I couldn't say aloud - my secret crush on Ethan Langford, my fantasies about running away to Paris, and tonight's entry, written in furious, ink-splotched letters:
I wish they'd just take the choice away. Make a rule - no clothes, ever. Not as punishment, but as law. So when people stare at the Hamilton girl, it's not because I chose wrong, but because I have no choice at all. Bind me to nakedness like our name's bound to that stupid trust fund. At least then when Mrs. Whitmore sniffs or James looks away, it won't be my fault.
The words shocked me even as I wrote them. I'd been angry before, but this... this was different. This felt dangerous.
The door creaked open without warning.
"Writing more treasonous manifestos?" Sarah leaned against the doorframe, still in her pool cover-up, damp hair leaving dark spots on the silk.
I snapped the journal shut. "Don't you knock?"
"Not when I bring gifts." She produced a stolen bottle of Perrier-Jouët from behind her back. "Ethan's downstairs if you want to—"
"I'm grounded, remember?"
Sarah rolled her eyes. "Because God forbid the Hamilton heir shows two inches of stomach." She flopped onto my bed, her cold feet brushing my leg. "You know what you need? A proper rebellion."
Breakfast the next morning was a silent affair. At the twelve-foot mahogany table, Father hid behind his Wall Street Journal while Mother dissected her grapefruit with surgical precision. Mrs. Whitmore hovered by the sideboard, her usual disapproving presence amplified after last night's drama.
Sarah arrived precisely at eight, as she had every morning since her parents' divorce three years prior. The Cartwrights might live next door in an equally ridiculous mansion, but Sarah had claimed the east wing guestroom years ago.
"Morning, Judge Hamilton," Sarah chirped, stealing a slice of toast from my plate. "Mr. Hamilton."
Father grunted. Mother offered a tight smile.
I stared at the congealing eggs on my plate, still seething. That's when Sarah dropped her bomb.
"So I was thinking," she began, swirling her orange juice like it was fine wine, "Annabel and I should make a little wager."
Father lowered his newspaper an inch.
Sarah's grin turned wicked. "If I win, Annie goes nude until graduation. No clothes, no exceptions. If she wins..." She paused dramatically. "I'll tutor her in calculus all semester."
Mrs. Whitmore gasped.
Mother's grapefruit spoon froze mid-bite. "That's hardly an equivalent exchange."
"Which makes it interesting," Father murmured, suddenly engaged. I could see the legal gears turning behind his eyes.
Sarah leaned forward, her charm offensive in full swing. "Think of it as... a lesson in consequences. The Hamilton way."
I should have protested. Should have recognized the trap. But the part of me that still burned with last night's humiliation... that part perked up.
The Contract, by evening, our casual bet had morphed into something far more sinister.
The library, with its floor-to-ceiling legal tomes and portraits of stern-faced Hamilton's past, became the setting for my undoing. Mother drafted clauses with her Montblanc pen, each stroke of ink another chain binding me. Father consulted precedent cases, muttering about "unenforceable" versus "airtight."
Sarah's father, Charles Cartwright - Mother's old law school rival - arrived with two associates and a bottle of 30-year Macallan. "For inspiration," he joked, though no one laughed.
"Section 4.7 stipulates no coverings exceeding twelve square inches," Mother recited, her reading glasses perched on her nose.
"Add a clause about school compliance," Father interjected.
Charles chuckled. "Might want to specify no temporary coverings during winter months."
I sat very still in the wingback chair, suddenly aware this had stopped being a joke. The contract now spanned seventeen pages, with exhibits. My chest tightened with each new provision.
Sarah, perched on the arm of my chair, squeezed my shoulder. "Cold feet?" she whispered.
I swallowed hard. "What exactly did you get out of this?"
Her smile didn't reach her eyes. "Let's just say your mother promised me something very special for my collection."
The notary arrived at eleven. As I signed my name - Annabel Grace Hamilton - the scratch of the pen sounded unnaturally loud.
Dawn on my fourteenth birthday found me standing before my empty wardrobe.
Sarah leaned against the doorframe, arms crossed, watching as Mrs. Whitmore and two maids systematically removed every garment I owned. Dresses, shoes, even the silk sleep masks - all vanished into black garment bags.
"Happy birthday," Sarah said, holding up the contract. "Time to pay up."
The marble floors were ice against my bare feet as I walked downstairs. The staff froze mid-motion - the young scullery maid dropped a tray, and James the butler blushed.
Mother looked up from her breakfast, her gaze sweeping over me with clinical detachment. "Posture, Annabel," she said calmly. "Hamilton doesn't sludge."
And with that, my new life began.
The first thing you should know about me is that my best friend sold me out for a pair of limited-edition Manolo Blahniks.
Sarah Cartwright and I had been inseparable since we were six years old when she pushed me off the swing set at Wellington Prep's kindergarten playground and then, seeing the knee she offered me her favorite hair ribbon as a peace offering. That was Sarah in a nutshell - she'd stab you in the back, then charm you with the knife still sticking out between your ribs.
Tonight, as I lay sprawled across my canopy bed staring at the water stains on the ceiling (even our fifteen-room manor had leaks), I could hear Sarah's laughter floating up from the garden below. She was probably lounging by the pool with Ethan and the twins, sipping the champagne Mrs. Whitmore didn't know they'd stolen from the cellar. I should have been down there with them. Would have been, if not for The Argument.
"Annabel Hamilton, you are not leaving this house dressed like a common streetwalker!"
Mother's voice still rang in my ears three hours later. Never mind that the "revealing outfit" in question was a perfectly modest knit sweater from Bergdorf's - it showed a sliver of midriff when I raised my arms, and that was enough to send the Hamilton household into lockdown.
I reached for my journal, the embossed leather cover worn smooth from years of use. This particular volume held everything I couldn't say aloud - my secret crush on Ethan Langford, my fantasies about running away to Paris, and tonight's entry, written in furious, ink-splotched letters:
I wish they'd just take the choice away. Make a rule - no clothes, ever. Not as punishment, but as law. So when people stare at the Hamilton girl, it's not because I chose wrong, but because I have no choice at all. Bind me to nakedness like our name's bound to that stupid trust fund. At least then when Mrs. Whitmore sniffs or James looks away, it won't be my fault.
The words shocked me even as I wrote them. I'd been angry before, but this... this was different. This felt dangerous.
The door creaked open without warning.
"Writing more treasonous manifestos?" Sarah leaned against the doorframe, still in her pool cover-up, damp hair leaving dark spots on the silk.
I snapped the journal shut. "Don't you knock?"
"Not when I bring gifts." She produced a stolen bottle of Perrier-Jouët from behind her back. "Ethan's downstairs if you want to—"
"I'm grounded, remember?"
Sarah rolled her eyes. "Because God forbid the Hamilton heir shows two inches of stomach." She flopped onto my bed, her cold feet brushing my leg. "You know what you need? A proper rebellion."
Breakfast the next morning was a silent affair. At the twelve-foot mahogany table, Father hid behind his Wall Street Journal while Mother dissected her grapefruit with surgical precision. Mrs. Whitmore hovered by the sideboard, her usual disapproving presence amplified after last night's drama.
Sarah arrived precisely at eight, as she had every morning since her parents' divorce three years prior. The Cartwrights might live next door in an equally ridiculous mansion, but Sarah had claimed the east wing guestroom years ago.
"Morning, Judge Hamilton," Sarah chirped, stealing a slice of toast from my plate. "Mr. Hamilton."
Father grunted. Mother offered a tight smile.
I stared at the congealing eggs on my plate, still seething. That's when Sarah dropped her bomb.
"So I was thinking," she began, swirling her orange juice like it was fine wine, "Annabel and I should make a little wager."
Father lowered his newspaper an inch.
Sarah's grin turned wicked. "If I win, Annie goes nude until graduation. No clothes, no exceptions. If she wins..." She paused dramatically. "I'll tutor her in calculus all semester."
Mrs. Whitmore gasped.
Mother's grapefruit spoon froze mid-bite. "That's hardly an equivalent exchange."
"Which makes it interesting," Father murmured, suddenly engaged. I could see the legal gears turning behind his eyes.
Sarah leaned forward, her charm offensive in full swing. "Think of it as... a lesson in consequences. The Hamilton way."
I should have protested. Should have recognized the trap. But the part of me that still burned with last night's humiliation... that part perked up.
The Contract, by evening, our casual bet had morphed into something far more sinister.
The library, with its floor-to-ceiling legal tomes and portraits of stern-faced Hamilton's past, became the setting for my undoing. Mother drafted clauses with her Montblanc pen, each stroke of ink another chain binding me. Father consulted precedent cases, muttering about "unenforceable" versus "airtight."
Sarah's father, Charles Cartwright - Mother's old law school rival - arrived with two associates and a bottle of 30-year Macallan. "For inspiration," he joked, though no one laughed.
"Section 4.7 stipulates no coverings exceeding twelve square inches," Mother recited, her reading glasses perched on her nose.
"Add a clause about school compliance," Father interjected.
Charles chuckled. "Might want to specify no temporary coverings during winter months."
I sat very still in the wingback chair, suddenly aware this had stopped being a joke. The contract now spanned seventeen pages, with exhibits. My chest tightened with each new provision.
Sarah, perched on the arm of my chair, squeezed my shoulder. "Cold feet?" she whispered.
I swallowed hard. "What exactly did you get out of this?"
Her smile didn't reach her eyes. "Let's just say your mother promised me something very special for my collection."
The notary arrived at eleven. As I signed my name - Annabel Grace Hamilton - the scratch of the pen sounded unnaturally loud.
Dawn on my fourteenth birthday found me standing before my empty wardrobe.
Sarah leaned against the doorframe, arms crossed, watching as Mrs. Whitmore and two maids systematically removed every garment I owned. Dresses, shoes, even the silk sleep masks - all vanished into black garment bags.
"Happy birthday," Sarah said, holding up the contract. "Time to pay up."
The marble floors were ice against my bare feet as I walked downstairs. The staff froze mid-motion - the young scullery maid dropped a tray, and James the butler blushed.
Mother looked up from her breakfast, her gaze sweeping over me with clinical detachment. "Posture, Annabel," she said calmly. "Hamilton doesn't sludge."
And with that, my new life began.
The brass coin felt unnaturally heavy in my palm as I slid it across the library desk toward Sarah. The Hamilton family crest gleamed under the chandelier's light - a lion holding a sword, just like the one woven into our estate's gates.
"You flip," I said, my voice steadier than I felt.
Sarah arched one perfectly groomed eyebrow. The Cartwright diamonds at her ears caught the light as she leaned forward. "Since when do you carry coins, Annie?"
Since yesterday. Since I'd paid the clockmaker on 43rd Street triple to weigh this one properly. Since I'd lain awake all night imagining the feel of open-air against bare skin with no choice, no blame, no more arguments about hemlines or straps or "appropriate attire for a Hamilton woman."
"Just flip it," I repeated.
The contract lay between us, its crisp pages fanned across Father's favorite mahogany desk. Mother had drafted the clauses with her usual ruthless precision - no clothing, no coverings, no exceptions for weather or occasions. Not on estate grounds. Not in town. Not ever.
Sarah plucked the coin from the desk with manicured fingers. "Heads, you lose everything." Her green eyes locked onto mine. "Tails... well." Her lips curved. "We both know it's not landing tails."
Across the room, Mother didn't look up from her correspondence. Father turned a page of his financial reports. Mrs. Whitmore hovered near the doorway, her usual disapproving presence suddenly irrelevant.
The coin caught the light as Sarah sent it spinning upward. I tracked its arc, my heart hammering against my ribcage. This was the moment. The point of no return.
Clink.
It hit the desk with finality.
Heads.
Of course.
Sarah's triumphant grin should have made me furious. Instead, something unclenched deep in my chest.
"No!" I shouted anyway, slamming my palms on the desk hard enough to make the inkwell rattle. "That's impossible! Flip it again!"
Mrs. Whitmore gasped. Mother finally looked up.
Sarah just laughed, twirling the coin across her knuckles with practiced ease. "A deal's a deal, Annie." She leaned in close enough that only I could hear. "Though we both know you rigged this better than I ever could."
My breath caught. She knew. Of course, she knew.
The grandfather clock in the hall struck noon as Mrs. Whitmore began ringing for the maids. They'd start in my dressing room, I knew. Every silk gown, every pair of leather shoes, every scrap of lace and linen would be gone by nightfall.
I should have felt panic. Dread. Instead, as Sarah pocketed the coin with a wink, I felt something dangerously close to relief.
The game was rigged.
I'd rigged it myself.
And now clothes would never be part of my life at Hamilton Estate again.
The morning after the coin toss, I awoke to empty closets.
Sunlight streamed through my bedroom windows, painting golden stripes across bare skin. For one disorienting moment, I forgot—then the unfamiliar sensation of cotton sheets against naked thighs sent the reality crashing back.
A knock came at the door.
"Up, Annie!" Sarah's singsong voice carried through the wood. "We're going out."
I clutched the sheet to my chest out of habit. "I'm not—"
The door swung open before I could finish. Sarah stood there, already dressed in a lavender sundress that made her tan glow, holding two iced coffees from my favorite café. Her eyes raked over me, still half-buried in bedding, and she smirked.
"Oh no," she said, setting one coffee on my nightstand and taking a deliberate sip from the other. "You don't get to hide here. The bet says "No clothes, do not stay in your room." She tossed her car keys in the air. "Up. Now."
My First Exposure: At the Garden Café, Sarah marched me straight to the most crowded brunch spot in the Hamptons.
The hostess's clipboard hit the ground when we approached. "I—uh—" Her eyes darted to my bare feet, then flickered up and immediately away. "Table for two?"
"Patio seating, please," Sarah said smoothly as if I weren't standing completely nude beside her.
Whispers followed us through the restaurant. A middle-aged woman gasped so loudly that she choked on her mimosa. Two finance bros at the bar stopped mid-sentence, one knocking over his Bloody Mary. But then—
"Annabel! Over here!"
Ethan Langford waved from a corner table, his smile only faltering for half a second when he registered my state of undress. His date—a willowy brunette from Brown University—blinked, then shrugged and scooted over to make room.
"New look?" Ethan asked as I sat, the wrought-iron chair cool against bare skin.
Sarah kicked me under the table before I could respond. "Annie lost a bet," she announced, loud enough for nearby tables to hear.
The brunette—Claire, apparently—leaned forward. "Honestly? Good for you. The tan lines must be a nightmare." And just like that, we were discussing summer skincare routines as if this were completely normal.
Our second stop was the Yacht Club where James drove us in the family Mercedes, his ears burning red the entire trip. Sarah had insisted on the convertible.
"Ms. Hamilton," the club manager stammered when we arrived, blocking the entrance with his clipboard. "There's a—that is to say—"
"House rule twenty-seven," Sarah recited sweetly. "No inappropriate attire. But Annie isn't wearing any attire at all, so technically..."
The manager's mustache twitched. Behind him, old Mr. Pembroke choked on his gin and tonic. A group of teenage boys near the docks suddenly found reasons to "check the rigging" on their father's sailboat.
But then Mrs. Van der Woodsen—eighty if she was a day—waved me over to her usual table. "Finally, someone embracing the Greek aesthetic," she declared, gesturing to the club's neoclassical architecture. "These modern fabrics are dreadful anyway."
I spent the afternoon sipping lemonade while Mrs. Van der Woodsen held court, her sharp commentary about club politics distracting everyone from my nudity.
Sarah saved the worst for last.
"Grab a basket," she ordered when James parked outside the gourmet market. My stomach twisted. This wasn't the sheltered world of country clubs and cafés—this was the real world.
The automatic doors hissed open.
A toddler pointed. "Mommy, that lady's—"
"Look, blueberries!" his mother yelped, yanking him down another aisle.
The butcher dropped a package of lamb chops.
An elderly stock boy offered me a sample of brie on a cracker without missing a beat. "New diet?" he asked, completely deadpan.
But the real surprise came in the frozen foods section.
"Annabel Hamilton?" A familiar voice made me turn. Mrs. Ruiz, my ninth-grade Spanish teacher, stood there with her shopping cart. Her gaze didn't waver. "I heard about your... situation." She nodded slowly. "Braver than I'd be in February."
Sarah burst out laughing. I almost joined her.
Back in my bedroom—now conspicuously lacking any robes or pajamas—Sarah flopped onto my bed, scrolling through her phone.
"Trending," she announced, turning the screen toward me.
There I was, caught in a dozen candid shots around town: carrying grocery bags with nothing but sunlight on my back, leaning against the yacht club railing with the wind in my hair, even one where Mrs. Van der Woodsen was draping a (non-clothing) floral garland over my shoulders like some modern-day Aphrodite.
The comments were a mixed bag:
"Rich girls will do anything for attention"
"Actually kind of iconic?"
"Wait, is this legal?"
"Free the nipple but also everything else I guess"
Sarah grinned. "Ready for round two tomorrow? I'm thinking of a beach club."
I threw a pillow at her. She dodged, laughing.
But as I settled under the sheets that night, skin still tingling from a day of sun and stares, the most surprising thought occurred to me:
Tomorrow wouldn't be so bad.
Sarah wasn't content with mere public appearances. By Sunday morning, she had orchestrated what could only be called a spectacle.
"Doubles match!" Sarah announced, tossing a racket at me in the middle of the Hamilton Estate's private courts.
I caught it on reflex, my bare feet sinking into the clay. "You can't be serious."
Across the net, Ethan Langford adjusted his sweatband with one hand while texting with the other. His partner—Victor McWebber, of all people—leaned on his racket, smirking.
"Five thousand says you can't take a set," Victor called, his eyes dragging over me in a way that wasn't quite sexual but wasn't either.
Sarah whispered in my ear: "They're donating to the youth center if we win."
The match became the most-watched tennis game in Hamptons history. By the third volley, the groundskeeper had set up folding chairs. By the second set, the club manager was selling lemonade.
And when I smashed the winning shot past Victor's smug face, the applause wasn't for the nudity—it was for the game.
Sarah insisted we eat in the main dining room. "Table by the window," she told the maître d', who turned pale but seated us without comment.
The reactions were predictable at first—clattering silverware, spilled wine, one elderly gentleman requiring smelling salts. Then something shifted.
"Miss Hamilton?" A nervous busboy approached. "My sister goes to Wellington. She said... that is..." He swallowed hard. "Could you sign her student handbook?"
Sarah nearly choked on her oysters.
By dessert, I'd signed seven autographs, two menus, and one very confused Labrador's collar.
Sarah had saved the most diabolical scheme for last.
"Life drawing class," she announced, pushing me through the doors of the community arts center. Twenty easels snapped up in unison.
The instructor—a wiry Frenchman with paint-stained jeans—barely glanced up. "Enfin, a model who understands vérité." He shoved a velvet cushion at me. "The chaise longue, if you please."
For two hours, I held poses while art students sketched. Not one snicker. No awkward stares. Just the scratch of charcoal and the occasional "tilt your chin left."
It was... peaceful.
Until Sarah auctioned the best sketch for charity.
Back in my bedroom—now sporting a light sunburn in interesting places—Sarah flopped onto my bed, scrolling through her phone.
"Your hashtag trending again," she said, showing me #NakedHeiress. "And before you protest—" She tapped the screen. "Look at the donations."
The numbers stunned me.
28,000 for the youth center.
28,000 for the youth center and 15,500 for arts education.
Even the grocers' association had started a "bare necessities" food drive.
Sarah's grin turned wicked. "Tomorrow? Wellington Academy." She tossed me a tube of sunscreen. "Better hydrate."
As the door clicked shut, I stared at my reflection in the floor-length mirror. The girl looking back wasn't hiding. Wasn't ashamed.
And that terrified me more than any naked tennis match ever could.
The gates of Wellington Academy loomed before me, their wrought-iron scrollwork suddenly feeling more like prison bars than prestigious architecture. My bare toes curled against the cobblestone driveway as the morning sun painted everything in cruel, revealing light.
Sarah leaned against the family Mercedes, already dressed in her uniform—skirt perfectly pleated, blazer cinched at the waist—while I stood exposed to the autumn breeze.
"Last chance to back out," she teased, twirling my discarded tie around her finger.
I swallowed hard. The car ride over had been one thing—James driving with military precision, eyes fixed firmly on the road—but this? This was the real test.
The first scream came from Maddie Cho as we rounded the corner to the senior quad.
"Oh my GOD!" Her Starbucks went flying, peppermint latte splattering across the pavement. "Annabel, what the—"
"Lost a bet," Sarah announced breezily, steering me through the gathering crowd.
By the time we reached the main building, the whispers had coalesced into a roaring tide:
"—doing it—"
"—think her nipples are cold?"
"—total psycho—"
"—kinda iconic though—"
Then the worst possible person appeared.
Victor McWebber leaned against my locker, his letterman jacket hanging open to reveal the "Naked Heiress" betting pool tally sheet pinned to his shirt. His smirk faltered for half a second when he saw me—saw me, shivering and exposed—before his usual arrogance snapped back into place.
"Hamilton." He whistled low. "Didn't think you'd show."
I reached past him to spin my combination lock, ignoring how close his body was to mine. "Move, McWebber."
The bell rang, saving me from further humiliation.
First Period: Advanced Calculus
Mr. Okafor blinked twice when I walked in, then immediately wrote "NO DISRUPTIVE BEHAVIOR" on the whiteboard in aggressive capital letters.
The room fell silent as I took my usual seat. Plastic chair. Bare skin. I'd never noticed how cold these damn chairs were.
Then Claire—Ethan's date from the café—slid into the desk beside mine and dropped a folded note on my lap.
Pantyhose sales have been down 300% since yesterday. Fashion brands in shambles.
I snorted so loud Mr. Okafor threatened detention.
Second Period: The Leak
Someone had taped pages from my journal to the humanities building bulletin board.
Not just any pages—the ones where I'd fantasized about this very scenario. The words "legally bound to nakedness" are circled in red marker, with anonymous notes scribbled in the margins:
Freak
Attention whore
Rich bitch stunt
But then, in different handwriting at the bottom:
Brave as hell
Sarah materialized beside me, her fingers closing around my wrist before I could tear the pages down. "Leave it," she murmured. "Let them see."
Lunchtime: The Pivot
The cafeteria fell silent when I walked in. Then, from the debate team table, a slow clap started.
Ethan stood, raising his chocolate milk in salute. "To Annabel Hamilton," he announced, "who just made the rest of us look like cowards."
A dozen cartons of milk were raised in response. Even Victor's lacrosse buddies joined in, though Victor himself just scowled into his turkey sandwich.
Sarah pressed a cold water bottle into my hand. "Told you," she whispered.
The Realization
By the final bell, something had shifted. The stares didn't stop, but their tenor changed—less leering, more curious. A freshman girl asked if I'd speak at the Women's Empowerment Club. The art teacher requested I model for figure drawing.
And when I passed Victor at his locker, he didn't make a joke. Just looked me up and down with an unreadable expression before muttering, "You're fucking insane, Hamilton."
But he held the door open for me on his way out.
Aftermath: The Mirror
That night, I stood before my bedroom mirror, studying the girl reflected there—sun-kissed shoulders, wind-tousled hair, no tan lines whatsoever.
Sarah's text buzzed on my nightstand: Media requests pouring in. Fashion brands offering "nude is the new black" sponsorships. You've started a movement, Annie.
I traced my collarbone in the glass, considering the dangerous thought that had been growing all day:
What if this wasn't a punishment?
What if it was liberation?
The document burned a hole through my desk drawer.
I'd read it seventeen times since discovering it last night, each pass revealing new horrors in the legalese. Moonlight bled through my curtains as I spread the pages across my bed, the final clause screaming up at me in twelve-point Times New Roman:
"Section 12.3: Termination of Agreement requires unanimous consent of all signing parties, including legal guardians, and shall not be revisited before the subject's eighteenth birthday. Thereafter, any extension to perpetuity requires only a majority vote of original signatories."
My fingers left damp prints on the paper. Perpetuity. The word slithered through my thoughts, coiling around my lungs.
A soft knock startled me.
"Annie?" Sarah's voice came muffled through the door. "Are you alive in there?"
I barely had time to shove the papers under my pillow before she entered, already dressed for Sunday brunch in a cream-colored sundress that made my nakedness feel even more obscene.
"You look like hell," she announced, flopping onto my bed. The documents crunched ominously beneath her weight.
"I—" My voice cracked. "Sarah. Did you know about Clause Twelve?"
Her smile didn't waver, but something flickered behind her eyes. "Which one was that again?"
I yanked the crumpled pages free and thrust them at her. "The one where this doesn't end unless everyone agrees!"
Sarah skimmed the text, her manicured nail tracing the damning lines. When she looked up, her expression was unreadable. "Huh. Guess the lawyers covered their bases."
The casualness of her response sent ice water through my veins. "You knew."
She stood abruptly, smoothing her dress. "What difference does it make? You wanted this."
"I wrote a journal entry!" My shout startled us both. "I didn't—this wasn't supposed to be—"
"Real?" Sarah arched a brow. "Please. You commissioned a weighted coin, Annie. You rigged the game yourself."
The truth of it stole my breath.
Sarah pocketed the documents with a shrug. "Anyway, Mother's calling a meeting tonight. Something about... opportunities." Her smile turned razor-sharp. "Wear something appropriate."
The Parlor
By seven PM, the estate's east parlor had transformed into a corporate war room. Mother sat at the head of the antique mahogany table, flanked by unfamiliar suits—designer-clad executives who didn't blink at my nudity, only at the potential revenue projections on their tablets.
"Annabel," Mother said without looking up, "meet the L'Oreal team. They're proposing a 'Bare Essentials' campaign."
A silver-haired woman extended a hand. "Your social media traction is extraordinary. We're thinking of billboards in Times Square—tasteful shadows, of course."
My stomach churned. Across the room, Sarah smirked over her champagne flute.
Then the door burst open.
Victor McWebber stood there, of all people, his lacrosse jacket askew and his usually perfect hair in disarray. He held a manila envelope marked CONFIDENTIAL in red.
"Sorry I'm late," he panted, ignoring the executives' stares. "Had to get these from my father's safe."
Mother's pen froze mid-signature. "What is the meaning—"
Victor tossed the envelope onto the table. Scattered legal slides spilled out—older documents, bearing the Cartwright family seal.
"Turns out," Victor said, his eyes locking onto mine, "this isn't the first time they've played this game."
The Revelation
The papers told a story in dry legal prose:
Twenty years ago. A different girl. Different bet. Same clauses.
Mother's name appeared as a witness.
Sarah's father is an enforcer.
And the subject?
A face I recognized from society pages—now Mrs. Astor, living in Switzerland, famously "reclusive."
The room spun.
Sarah's champagne flute shattered on the parquet.
Mother stood abruptly. "This meeting is adjourned."
Midnight Confessional
I found Victor at the boathouse, hurling rocks into the dark water.
"Why?" My voice sounded raw.
He didn't turn. "Because the pool was bullshit." Another rock sailed into the night. "And because..." His jaw worked. "You looked at me in calc today like I was the villain."
The admission hung between us.
I stepped closer, the dock's weathered planks rough under bare feet. "What happens now?"
Victor finally faced me, moonlight carving shadows across his features. "Now?" He reached into his jacket, producing a single key. "Now we break into Cartwright's study."
The Clock Ticks
As we slipped through the hedge divide between estates, three truths became clear:
This was never just a bet.
Sarah played a longer game than I imagined.
That clause about perpetuity?
It wasn't added for me.
It was copied from hers.
The Binding Bet
-
- Posts: 56
- Joined: Sat Dec 23, 2023 11:15 pm
- Has thanked: 1 time
- Been thanked: 155 times
- Contact:
Chapter 2: The Choice
Chapter 2: The Choice
The Cartwright study smelled of leather and lies.
Moonlight sliced through the velvet curtains as Victor's stolen key turned in the antique lock. Inside, the mahogany-paneled walls held portraits of stern-faced Cartwright's past, their painted eyes following us as we moved toward the vault hidden behind a false bookshelf.
Victor's hands shook as he punched in the code. "My dad was their estate lawyer," he murmured. "Kept copies of everything. Insurance, he said."
The vault door swung open with a sigh.
Inside, neatly labeled folders stretched back decades. My fingers found the one marked A.A. first—the reclusive Mrs. Astor, her teenage portrait showing a girl not unlike me, clothed but with hollow eyes. Beneath it lay others: G.W. '98, L.S. '04, each containing identical contracts with that damning Clause 12.
But it was the videotapes that stopped my heart.
Security footage showed each girl in their "transition period"—being paraded at parties, photographed at galas, always nude, always with that same glassy stare. Training footage. Conditioning.
Victor made a strangled noise. "Jesus Christ."
I should have felt horror. Revulsion. Instead, a terrible clarity settled over me.
They'd wanted broken dolls.
And I'd refused to break.
Morning: The Ultimatum
I walked into breakfast naked for the 38th consecutive morning.
Mother barely glanced up from her tablet. "The L'Oreal deal requires—"
"I know about Amelia Astor."
The room froze. Mrs. Whitmore dropped the silver serving tray with a clatter.
Father's newspaper lowered by inches. "That's enough, Annabel."
But it wasn't. It would never be enough again.
I placed the stolen contracts on the linen tablecloth. "How many others?"
Mother's composure cracked for just an instant—a flash of something like fear—before smoothing into her usual icy calm. "You don't understand the privilege—"
"I accept."
Silence.
Sarah, halfway through buttering a scone, froze. "What?"
I met Mother's gaze squarely. "The perpetuity clause. I want it enacted."
Victor's fork clattered to his plate. "Have you lost your fucking mind?"
But I'd never seen clearer. They'd built this game to break girls into perfect, pliable society wives. To teach us that our bodies weren't ours. That shame was inevitable.
Well.
I'd play.
But not by their rules.
The Signing
The lawyers arrived within the hour.
Mother watched, tight-lipped, as I initialed every page without reading. Father kept rubbing his temple like this was a minor inconvenience. Sarah—for the first time since kindergarten—looked genuinely afraid.
"You don't have to do this," Victor whispered as the notary prepared his seal.
I smiled. "I know."
The pen felt heavy in my hand as I signed the final amendment:
Annabel Grace Hamilton, in sound mind and body, hereby voluntarily extends the terms of this agreement in perpetuity.
The notary's stamp came down with finality.
Thud.
Evening: The First Move
I stood before the floor-length mirror as the summer sunset, studying the girl who'd chosen this.
No more contracts.
No more bets.
Just me.
When the door creaked open, I didn't turn.
Sarah hovered in the doorway, her usual confidence frayed. "Why?"
I met her reflection's gaze. "Because now when they stare, it's my choice."
The truth settled between us—this was never her game.
It was mine.
The morning after signing away my right to clothing forever, I woke to a world that had shifted on its axis.
Sunlight streamed through my windows, painting golden stripes across bare skin that would never again know the whisper of fabric. The empty walk-in closet stood with its doors thrown wide—a monument to my defiance.
I stretched, savoring the unfamiliar sensation of complete freedom.
Then I threw open my bedroom door and strode downstairs to breakfast.
The Breakfast Gauntlet
The staff froze mid-motion as I entered the dining room. Mrs. Whitmore's knuckles went white around the coffee carafe. James dropped his serving tray—the third time this week.
Mother looked up from her tablet, her carefully curated mask of composure slipping for just an instant. "Annabel. You're... early."
I took my seat with deliberate grace, the polished mahogany cool against my thighs. "Hungry," I said, reaching for the berry bowl.
Father's newspaper rustled as he peeked over the edge. "About last night—"
"Water under the bridge," I said, popping a blackberry into my mouth. The juice stained my lips purple. "Though I do have one condition."
Mother's eyebrow arched. "Condition?"
I smiled. "I want my journal pages back."
The Media Storm
By noon, #NakedHeiress was trending globally.
News vans camped at our gates. Fashion brands scrambled to align with or condemn my "statement." The Wellington Academy headmaster issued a bewildered press release about "accommodating unique educational circumstances."
But the real surprise came at 12:37 PM when @VictorMcWebber tweeted:
"Turns out courage looks better naked than any of us. #TeamHamilton"
Attached was a scanned document—the original Cartwright bet from 2003, with Mother's signature clear as day in the witness line.
The internet exploded.
Sarah's Reckoning
I found her in the east wing parlor, shredding documents with frantic hands.
"They were never supposed to see the light," she muttered, not looking up as I entered. "It was just... tradition."
The carpet crunched underfoot—shredded contracts dating back decades. I knelt, retrieving a half-torn photograph: a young Amelia Astor, nude and hollow-eyed at some long-ago garden party.
"Your father's idea?" I asked quietly.
Sarah's hands stilled. "Grandfather's." She laughed bitterly. "The great Cartwright legacy—breaking society girls before society could."
I studied my oldest friend—really studied her—and saw for the first time the fear behind her perfect facade. "You were next, weren't you?"
The silence answered for her.
The World Responds
By week's end:
Three Cartwright board members resigned
L'Oreal canceled their "Bare Essentials" campaign
The Times ran a think piece titled "The Empowering Nudity of the Privileged?"
And to everyone's shock, Amelia Astor flew in from Switzerland
Her press conference broke the internet.
Standing fully clothed at a podium, the now-forty-year-old woman spoke for exactly two minutes:
"I was the first. Annabel will be the last. That's all."
Then she walked offstage, leaving a hundred flashing cameras in her wake.
The New Normal
Monday morning found me standing before Wellington Academy's gates—not slinking, not ashamed, but shoulders back and chin high.
The crowd parted silently.
Victor fell into step beside me, uncharacteristically serious. "You know this isn't over, right?"
I adjusted the strap of my bookbag—the only item I carried—and smiled. "I'm counting on it."
Inside, the halls buzzed. Some students averted their eyes. Others nodded respectfully. Claire from calculus handed me a sticky note:
Study group at my place on Friday. Mom says to wear whatever (or not).
But the real surprise waited at my locker.
Taped to the metal door was a single sheet of paper—a photocopy of Clause 12, with one crucial addition in red ink:
"Voided by unanimous consent of all living subjects."
Beneath it, are three signatures:
Amelia Astor.
Annabel Hamilton.
And, in shaky script... Sarah Cartwright.
Epilogue: One Month Later
The Hamilton Estate pool party became a legend.
Naked debutantes splashed alongside clothed friends. Paparazzi helicopters circled uselessly (we'd hired snipers). And when Mother attempted to retreat indoors, Amelia Astor—resplendent in a Chanel pantsuit—handed her a cocktail and said, "Try keeping up, Eleanor."
As fireworks exploded overhead, Sarah found me lounging on a float.
"Still think you won?" she asked, toeing the water.
I looked around at the laughing crowd—at Victor doing cannonballs in his boxers, at Ethan debating philosophy with a fully nude debate team member, at Amelia holding court like the queen she was.
Then I smiled up at my oldest friend.
"We all did."
Five Years Later - The Amelia Astor Center for Bodily Autonomy
The glass-walled conference room buzzed with energy as I adjusted the microphone on my lapel—the only article of clothing I’d worn in half a decade. Outside, Manhattan glittered beneath us, a far cry from the gilded cages of the Hamptons.
Amelia, now my business partner and unlikely mentor, gave me a nod from across the table where she sat fully clothed in a tailored suit. Some scars ran too deep.
“Ready to change the world again, Hamilton?” she murmured.
I grinned. “Always.”
The press filed in, their cameras already flashing. At the back of the room, Victor—now a civil rights attorney—winked as he shepherded in a group of nervous-looking teenagers. The newest clients. The next generation.
The Movement
What began as my rebellion had become something bigger:
#SkinIsNotSin trended annually during Fashion Week as designers sent models down runways in varying states of undress
Six states amended public decency laws to exclude non-sexual nudity
The Hamilton-Cartwright Scholarship (funded by our families’ hush money) sent thirty-seven unconventional women to college
But the real victory was quieter.
Sarah’s Redemption
She found me on the Center’s rooftop garden at dusk, clutching two champagne flutes.
“To tradition,” she said dryly, handing me one.
I clinked my glass against hers. “To break it.”
Below us, the city pulsed with life—a living, breathing thing that had absorbed our scandal and transformed it into progress. Sarah had traded manipulation for activism, her sharp mind now defending others against the system she’d once upheld.
“Do you ever miss it?” she asked suddenly. “The game?”
I looked down at my bare legs, at the sun-warmed skin that had become my second nature. “This was never a game, Sarah.”
The Unexpected Ripple
Victor’s TED Talk clip played on the lobby screens:
“We taught girls their bodies were problems to be solved. Annabel Hamilton proved they’re revolutions waiting to happen.”
Beside it, a live feed showed Wellington Academy’s annual “Clause 12 Remembrance Day,” where students—clothed and unclothed—debated consent and bodily autonomy.
Epilogue: Ten Years Later
The photograph went viral:
Amelia, fully suited, shaking hands with a nervous new client.
Sarah, in a daring backless gown, argued before the Supreme Court.
Victor, shirtless in solidarity, holding our toddler daughter—who wore nothing but glittery face paint and a determined smile.
And me.
Still naked.
Still free.
Still rewriting the rules.
The world spins forward. The legacy lives on as this story ends, or is it a beginning…
The Cartwright study smelled of leather and lies.
Moonlight sliced through the velvet curtains as Victor's stolen key turned in the antique lock. Inside, the mahogany-paneled walls held portraits of stern-faced Cartwright's past, their painted eyes following us as we moved toward the vault hidden behind a false bookshelf.
Victor's hands shook as he punched in the code. "My dad was their estate lawyer," he murmured. "Kept copies of everything. Insurance, he said."
The vault door swung open with a sigh.
Inside, neatly labeled folders stretched back decades. My fingers found the one marked A.A. first—the reclusive Mrs. Astor, her teenage portrait showing a girl not unlike me, clothed but with hollow eyes. Beneath it lay others: G.W. '98, L.S. '04, each containing identical contracts with that damning Clause 12.
But it was the videotapes that stopped my heart.
Security footage showed each girl in their "transition period"—being paraded at parties, photographed at galas, always nude, always with that same glassy stare. Training footage. Conditioning.
Victor made a strangled noise. "Jesus Christ."
I should have felt horror. Revulsion. Instead, a terrible clarity settled over me.
They'd wanted broken dolls.
And I'd refused to break.
Morning: The Ultimatum
I walked into breakfast naked for the 38th consecutive morning.
Mother barely glanced up from her tablet. "The L'Oreal deal requires—"
"I know about Amelia Astor."
The room froze. Mrs. Whitmore dropped the silver serving tray with a clatter.
Father's newspaper lowered by inches. "That's enough, Annabel."
But it wasn't. It would never be enough again.
I placed the stolen contracts on the linen tablecloth. "How many others?"
Mother's composure cracked for just an instant—a flash of something like fear—before smoothing into her usual icy calm. "You don't understand the privilege—"
"I accept."
Silence.
Sarah, halfway through buttering a scone, froze. "What?"
I met Mother's gaze squarely. "The perpetuity clause. I want it enacted."
Victor's fork clattered to his plate. "Have you lost your fucking mind?"
But I'd never seen clearer. They'd built this game to break girls into perfect, pliable society wives. To teach us that our bodies weren't ours. That shame was inevitable.
Well.
I'd play.
But not by their rules.
The Signing
The lawyers arrived within the hour.
Mother watched, tight-lipped, as I initialed every page without reading. Father kept rubbing his temple like this was a minor inconvenience. Sarah—for the first time since kindergarten—looked genuinely afraid.
"You don't have to do this," Victor whispered as the notary prepared his seal.
I smiled. "I know."
The pen felt heavy in my hand as I signed the final amendment:
Annabel Grace Hamilton, in sound mind and body, hereby voluntarily extends the terms of this agreement in perpetuity.
The notary's stamp came down with finality.
Thud.
Evening: The First Move
I stood before the floor-length mirror as the summer sunset, studying the girl who'd chosen this.
No more contracts.
No more bets.
Just me.
When the door creaked open, I didn't turn.
Sarah hovered in the doorway, her usual confidence frayed. "Why?"
I met her reflection's gaze. "Because now when they stare, it's my choice."
The truth settled between us—this was never her game.
It was mine.
The morning after signing away my right to clothing forever, I woke to a world that had shifted on its axis.
Sunlight streamed through my windows, painting golden stripes across bare skin that would never again know the whisper of fabric. The empty walk-in closet stood with its doors thrown wide—a monument to my defiance.
I stretched, savoring the unfamiliar sensation of complete freedom.
Then I threw open my bedroom door and strode downstairs to breakfast.
The Breakfast Gauntlet
The staff froze mid-motion as I entered the dining room. Mrs. Whitmore's knuckles went white around the coffee carafe. James dropped his serving tray—the third time this week.
Mother looked up from her tablet, her carefully curated mask of composure slipping for just an instant. "Annabel. You're... early."
I took my seat with deliberate grace, the polished mahogany cool against my thighs. "Hungry," I said, reaching for the berry bowl.
Father's newspaper rustled as he peeked over the edge. "About last night—"
"Water under the bridge," I said, popping a blackberry into my mouth. The juice stained my lips purple. "Though I do have one condition."
Mother's eyebrow arched. "Condition?"
I smiled. "I want my journal pages back."
The Media Storm
By noon, #NakedHeiress was trending globally.
News vans camped at our gates. Fashion brands scrambled to align with or condemn my "statement." The Wellington Academy headmaster issued a bewildered press release about "accommodating unique educational circumstances."
But the real surprise came at 12:37 PM when @VictorMcWebber tweeted:
"Turns out courage looks better naked than any of us. #TeamHamilton"
Attached was a scanned document—the original Cartwright bet from 2003, with Mother's signature clear as day in the witness line.
The internet exploded.
Sarah's Reckoning
I found her in the east wing parlor, shredding documents with frantic hands.
"They were never supposed to see the light," she muttered, not looking up as I entered. "It was just... tradition."
The carpet crunched underfoot—shredded contracts dating back decades. I knelt, retrieving a half-torn photograph: a young Amelia Astor, nude and hollow-eyed at some long-ago garden party.
"Your father's idea?" I asked quietly.
Sarah's hands stilled. "Grandfather's." She laughed bitterly. "The great Cartwright legacy—breaking society girls before society could."
I studied my oldest friend—really studied her—and saw for the first time the fear behind her perfect facade. "You were next, weren't you?"
The silence answered for her.
The World Responds
By week's end:
Three Cartwright board members resigned
L'Oreal canceled their "Bare Essentials" campaign
The Times ran a think piece titled "The Empowering Nudity of the Privileged?"
And to everyone's shock, Amelia Astor flew in from Switzerland
Her press conference broke the internet.
Standing fully clothed at a podium, the now-forty-year-old woman spoke for exactly two minutes:
"I was the first. Annabel will be the last. That's all."
Then she walked offstage, leaving a hundred flashing cameras in her wake.
The New Normal
Monday morning found me standing before Wellington Academy's gates—not slinking, not ashamed, but shoulders back and chin high.
The crowd parted silently.
Victor fell into step beside me, uncharacteristically serious. "You know this isn't over, right?"
I adjusted the strap of my bookbag—the only item I carried—and smiled. "I'm counting on it."
Inside, the halls buzzed. Some students averted their eyes. Others nodded respectfully. Claire from calculus handed me a sticky note:
Study group at my place on Friday. Mom says to wear whatever (or not).
But the real surprise waited at my locker.
Taped to the metal door was a single sheet of paper—a photocopy of Clause 12, with one crucial addition in red ink:
"Voided by unanimous consent of all living subjects."
Beneath it, are three signatures:
Amelia Astor.
Annabel Hamilton.
And, in shaky script... Sarah Cartwright.
Epilogue: One Month Later
The Hamilton Estate pool party became a legend.
Naked debutantes splashed alongside clothed friends. Paparazzi helicopters circled uselessly (we'd hired snipers). And when Mother attempted to retreat indoors, Amelia Astor—resplendent in a Chanel pantsuit—handed her a cocktail and said, "Try keeping up, Eleanor."
As fireworks exploded overhead, Sarah found me lounging on a float.
"Still think you won?" she asked, toeing the water.
I looked around at the laughing crowd—at Victor doing cannonballs in his boxers, at Ethan debating philosophy with a fully nude debate team member, at Amelia holding court like the queen she was.
Then I smiled up at my oldest friend.
"We all did."
Five Years Later - The Amelia Astor Center for Bodily Autonomy
The glass-walled conference room buzzed with energy as I adjusted the microphone on my lapel—the only article of clothing I’d worn in half a decade. Outside, Manhattan glittered beneath us, a far cry from the gilded cages of the Hamptons.
Amelia, now my business partner and unlikely mentor, gave me a nod from across the table where she sat fully clothed in a tailored suit. Some scars ran too deep.
“Ready to change the world again, Hamilton?” she murmured.
I grinned. “Always.”
The press filed in, their cameras already flashing. At the back of the room, Victor—now a civil rights attorney—winked as he shepherded in a group of nervous-looking teenagers. The newest clients. The next generation.
The Movement
What began as my rebellion had become something bigger:
#SkinIsNotSin trended annually during Fashion Week as designers sent models down runways in varying states of undress
Six states amended public decency laws to exclude non-sexual nudity
The Hamilton-Cartwright Scholarship (funded by our families’ hush money) sent thirty-seven unconventional women to college
But the real victory was quieter.
Sarah’s Redemption
She found me on the Center’s rooftop garden at dusk, clutching two champagne flutes.
“To tradition,” she said dryly, handing me one.
I clinked my glass against hers. “To break it.”
Below us, the city pulsed with life—a living, breathing thing that had absorbed our scandal and transformed it into progress. Sarah had traded manipulation for activism, her sharp mind now defending others against the system she’d once upheld.
“Do you ever miss it?” she asked suddenly. “The game?”
I looked down at my bare legs, at the sun-warmed skin that had become my second nature. “This was never a game, Sarah.”
The Unexpected Ripple
Victor’s TED Talk clip played on the lobby screens:
“We taught girls their bodies were problems to be solved. Annabel Hamilton proved they’re revolutions waiting to happen.”
Beside it, a live feed showed Wellington Academy’s annual “Clause 12 Remembrance Day,” where students—clothed and unclothed—debated consent and bodily autonomy.
Epilogue: Ten Years Later
The photograph went viral:
Amelia, fully suited, shaking hands with a nervous new client.
Sarah, in a daring backless gown, argued before the Supreme Court.
Victor, shirtless in solidarity, holding our toddler daughter—who wore nothing but glittery face paint and a determined smile.
And me.
Still naked.
Still free.
Still rewriting the rules.
The world spins forward. The legacy lives on as this story ends, or is it a beginning…
-
- Posts: 143
- Joined: Sat Nov 18, 2023 11:32 pm
- Has thanked: 428 times
- Been thanked: 329 times
- Contact:
-
- Posts: 364
- Joined: Wed Nov 06, 2019 10:10 am
- Has thanked: 830 times
- Been thanked: 580 times
- Contact:
Re: The Binding Bet
Absolutely wonderful story! Looking forward to reading what happens next.
If you don't mind me saying, however, your post needs some serious editing as the first introductory 39 paragraphs are repeated in their entirety - word for word - half way down the page. I am sure this wasn't intentional.
Again, thanks for a very interesting read!
Hooked6
If you don't mind me saying, however, your post needs some serious editing as the first introductory 39 paragraphs are repeated in their entirety - word for word - half way down the page. I am sure this wasn't intentional.
Again, thanks for a very interesting read!
Hooked6
-
- Posts: 51
- Joined: Tue Mar 12, 2024 10:04 pm
- Has thanked: 97 times
- Been thanked: 134 times
- Contact:
Re: The Binding Bet
Apart from the editing error, it is a great read creating a scenario with a twist. Very well rounded story. Thank you
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Debbifan and 22 guests