The Unraveling (New 7/13)

[Bucket]

Wow. What an absolutely outstanding chapter! Chapter 51 is undoubtedly one of the best yet. Thoroughly enjoyed this latest chapter, and damn did I love the way Riley came. Keep up the great work, Emily!

[Emily]

A new chapter (maybe even 2) should be ready this weekend!

I’ve been feeling very turned on and inspired, so this weekend feels like a good time for some naughty naked writing

I’d love to continue hearing any feedback or ideas!

[Emily]

Chapter 52

Riley’s body stiffened at the sound of her brother’s voice, and she took a shaky breath. She didn’t want to face the reality of what had just happened, the way she had given in to the twisted game they had been forced to play. She felt used, violated, and the last thing she wanted was to have to explain herself. “Please, Jake,” she mumbled into the pillow. “Not now. I can’t take any more tonight. Let’s just...let’s talk about it tomorrow morning, okay?”

Jake sighed, his hand still hovering over his erection, unsure of what to do with it. “Fine,” he said gruffly. “But we are going to talk about this. And you’re not getting out of this. I want to know what’s going on, and I want to know why you sent me that picture.”

Lily looked at him, the cum still glistening on her cheeks and chin. “We’ll explain everything tomorrow, I promise,” she said softly, her voice filled with a mix of fear and hope. “Just...please, let us get some sleep. We’re all exhausted and overwhelmed right now. We need some time to think about what happened.”

Jake nodded slowly, his eyes still flicking over the two naked bodies on the bed. He knew he should feel guilty, should tell them to get dressed, to never speak of this again. But the lust in him was too strong, the curiosity burning in his mind too intense. He stood up, adjusting his erection before it became too obvious. “Okay,” he said, his voice still thick with desire. “But we talk tomorrow, first thing. And I mean it. No hiding from this, no pretending it didn’t happen.”

The two girls nodded, and as one, they stood up, not bothering to cover their nakedness. Riley’s legs were wobbly, the aftershocks of her orgasm still pulsing through her, and she had to grab the bedpost to steady herself. Lily was more composed, but the look in her eyes was haunted, as if she couldn’t believe what had just happened. They both gathered their clothes, the fabric feeling alien in their hands after the intense experience they had just shared.

They made their way back to Riley’s room, the silence between them thick with unspoken words and unanswered questions. The hallway felt eerily long, each step echoing in the quiet of the night. Riley’s heart was racing, her thoughts a jumble of fear and confusion. What would happen tomorrow when the lights of day shone on their actions?

As they entered the room, she didn’t bother with modesty, leaving her clothes in a pile by the door. Her mind was a blur, unable to process the reality of the situation. Lily followed suit, the two of them standing naked in the soft glow of the bedside lamp, their bodies still flushed from the recent orgasm.

Riley’s thoughts raced as she sat down on the bed, her legs still trembling. “How did this happen?” she whispered to herself, her eyes wide with panic. “What have we done?”

Lily approached her, her own face a canvas of emotions—concern, confusion, and fear. “Riley, we need to tell Ellie, Aria, and Claire what happened tonight,” she said firmly.

Riley's eyes widened in horror. “What? Why would we do that?”

“Maybe they can help us figure this out,” Lily continued, her voice gentle yet firm. “Plus if they found out from someone else, it would be so much worse. We need to get ahead of this, Riles.”

Riley's mind spun with the implications. Lily was right; they couldn't just pretend this had never happened. With shaking hands, she reached for her phone on the nightstand, her thoughts racing as she composed a group text to Ellie, Aria, and Claire.

“Help! We need to talk now!” Riley typed, her trembling fingers barely managing to hit the send button. The message shot off into the digital abyss, and she could only hope that it would bring them the relief they desperately needed. She felt like she was drowning in a sea of her own making, the weight of her actions pressing down on her like an invisible hand.

Almost immediately, her phone rang, the shrill sound cutting through the thick silence like a knife. She glanced at the screen—it was Claire. Lily’s eyes met hers, filled with a mix of dread and hope. They both took a deep breath and Riley hit accept. “What happened?” Claire’s voice was frantic, and Riley could almost hear the gears turning in her head as she tried to piece together what could have possibly gone so wrong.

“It’s my brother, Jake. He... he saw us,” Riley choked out, the words catching in her throat. She could feel Lily’s eyes on her, but she couldn’t bring herself to look at her friend. “And he made us finish… in front of him.” Her voice trailed off as a fresh wave of humiliation washed over her.

“So?” Claire’s voice was icy cold. “What’s the big deal?”

“He recognized my pussy from the photo you guys sent him,” Riley whispered into the phone, her voice trembling with the gravity of the situation. The silence on the other end was deafening, and she could almost feel Claire’s eyes boring into her through the screen. “And now he wants an explanation for everything.”

For a moment, it seemed like Claire was going to laugh it off, but then she spoke, her tone sharper than a knife's edge. "Fuck. That could be a problem." Riley could almost see the cogs turning in her mind as she weighed her options. "Alright, I'll deal with this. But it's going to cost you two."

Riley felt a cold knot form in her stomach. "What do you mean, 'cost us'?" she asked, her voice small and trembling.

"It means," Claire said with a sigh, "that if you want this to go away, if you want Jake to keep his mouth shut and not ruin everything for you and Lily, you're going to have to be willing to do whatever it takes. And when I say 'whatever', I mean exactly that."

“Fine.” Riley agreed. “How are we going to fix this?”

“Well, for starters, I need to know if you have any time alone with him tomorrow. Can you manage that?” Claire’s voice was firm, almost demanding.

Riley thought quickly. “Our parents are going to church tomorrow. They’re usually gone the whole morning. We’ll be home alone until afternoon.”

“Perfect,” Claire purred into the phone. “Send me the address, and I’ll come over and sort this out. I’ve got a few tricks up my sleeve that’ll make him forget he ever saw anything. Trust me, I know how to handle guys like him.”

Riley nodded, though she couldn’t shake the feeling of dread that had settled in the pit of her stomach. “Okay, I’ll text it to you now.” Her hands trembled as she sent the message, feeling like she was handing over the last shred of her dignity.

Claire’s response was swift. “Good girl. Now, go clean yourselves up and get some rest. You’re going to need it for what I’ve got planned for tomorrow. And don’t worry, I’ll make sure this all goes away.”

With that, she hung up, leaving Riley and Lily in a tense silence. They both knew that they had to follow through with whatever Claire had in mind. There was no other choice. They shared a look, a silent understanding passing between them.

They took turns showering, the hot water washing away the sticky remnants of their shared orgasm, but not the memory of it. Riley couldn’t help but feel a little dirty, a little used, as she rinsed off. Lily was quiet as she scrubbed herself clean, her eyes avoiding the mirror. They both knew that the real cleaning was going to take much more than soap and water.

Once they were both out of the shower, they climbed into bed. The silence was heavy, thick with the weight of their shared secret and the impending confrontation with Jake. Riley’s mind raced with fear and anticipation of what tomorrow would bring, but eventually, the warmth of the blankets and the comfort of Lily’s presence beside her began to lull her into a fitful sleep.

They woke up early the next morning, the light of dawn barely peeking through the curtains. Riley’s eyes snapped open, the events of the night before rushing back to her in a flood of memories. She glanced over at Lily, who was still sleeping soundly, her breathing deep and even. For a moment, she considered waking her up to talk, but she didn’t have the energy to deal with it yet. Instead, she slid out of bed, her bare feet hitting the cold floor with a jolt.

Before too long, Lily’s eyes fluttered open, the light of the early morning sun casting a soft glow across her face. She blinked a few times, orienting herself to the unfamiliar surroundings before the events of the night before crashed into her memory like a wrecking ball. Her eyes searched the room, finding Riley already dressed and sitting on the edge of the bed. Lily followed her friend's lead, getting dressed and trying to compose herself.

“What do you think she has planned for us?” Lily whispered, her voice tight with anxiety.

Riley’s stomach churned as she thought of Claire’s cryptic message. “I don’t know, but I have a feeling it’s not going to be good,” she replied, her eyes darting around the room as if expecting the older girl to appear at any moment.

In perfect timing, Riley’s phone buzzed on the bedside table. She snatched it up, her eyes scanning the screen with a mix of dread and hope. It was a text from Claire: “Almost there. Make sure the coast is clear.” Riley let out a sigh of relief. Her parents had left early for their weekly church service, giving them the perfect opportunity to handle this situation without any interruptions.

They both moved quickly, making the bed and straightening up the room, trying to erase any signs of their nocturnal activities. The nervous energy between them was palpable, their movements jerky and erratic. The clock on the wall seemed to tick louder than ever before, each second stretching out like a tightly coiled spring waiting to snap.

Finally, the moment of truth arrived as the sound of the knock echoed through the quiet house. Riley and Lily shared a panicked look before Riley took a deep breath and moved to answer it. She pulled the door open, her heart racing as she found Claire standing there with a knowing smirk on her face.

“Good morning, girls,” Claire greeted them, her eyes sweeping over their nervous forms with a predatory gaze. “Ready to get this sorted?”

Riley nodded, her throat too dry to speak, while Lily managed a weak, “Yeah, let’s just get this over with.”

Claire stepped into the room, her eyes sweeping over the two of them, taking in every detail. She closed the door behind her with a deliberate click that seemed to echo in the silence. "Alright, first things first," she announced, her voice low and commanding. "Strip. Now."

Riley felt a cold shiver run down her spine at the word, but she didn't hesitate. She knew better than to argue with Claire, especially not now. She slowly peeled off her clothes, her eyes on the floor as she exposed herself once again to her friend's gaze. Lily followed suit, her movements more robotic than Riley's, as if she were going through the motions of a dance she had performed too many times.

Once they were both naked, Claire nodded, a smug smile playing at the corners of her mouth. "Good," she said. "Now, I want you to lead me to Jake."

They both nodded and walked down the hallway, the sound of their bare feet on the cold floor echoing through the house. Riley's heart hammered in her chest as they approached the door to her brother's room. She took a deep breath and pushed it open, her hand shaking as she did so.

Jake was still asleep, sprawled out on his bed, the blankets tangled around his waist. His chest rose and fell evenly, oblivious to the storm brewing outside his door. Claire stepped into the room, her eyes scanning the space with a critical eye. She walked over to the bed, her hips swaying with a confidence that made Riley feel even more vulnerable.

"Wake up, Jake," she called out, her voice a seductive purr. "Your sister and her friend have something to tell you."

Jake's eyes snapped open, blinking in the early morning light. He sat up with a start, the sheets falling away from his bare chest, and took in the sight before him. Riley and Lily, both naked, stood by the door, looking as though they had seen a ghost. His eyes widened in shock, the fog of sleep dissipating rapidly.

"What the hell is going on here?" he demanded, his voice thick with sleep and confusion. "And who are you?" He jerked his head in Claire's direction, his gaze narrowing as he took in her smug expression.

"I'm Claire," she said, her voice dripping with sweetness. "And I'm here to explain everything." She sauntered over to the bed, her movements deliberate and cat-like, and perched on the edge. She was dressed in a tight-fitting dress that hugged her curves in all the right places, her hair falling in soft waves around her shoulders. Riley felt a flash of jealousy at the confidence that seemed to ooze from every pore of her body.

Jake looked at the three of them, his eyes still wide with shock. Riley could feel his gaze on her, his eyes roaming over her bare skin. She wanted to shrink away, to cover herself, but she knew that would only make it worse. Lily stood beside her, equally naked and equally uncomfortable. They had agreed to do whatever Claire said, to make this go away.

"Jake," Claire began, her voice low and commanding. "These two are mine. You see, we have an understanding. They do as I say, and I protect them. It's a simple arrangement." She leaned in closer, her hand tracing the line of his jaw, and Riley felt a jolt of something akin to possessiveness at the way she touched him. "And if you mess with what's mine, you'll regret it."

Jake's eyes narrowed as he took in Claire's words. Riley watched as the gears turned in his head, trying to piece together the puzzle that was unfolding before him. He looked from her to Lily and then back again, his expression unreadable.

"What the fuck are you talking about?" he spat, his voice a mix of anger and confusion.

Claire chuckled, a dark sound that sent shivers down Riley's spine. "You see, Jake, your sister and her friend are my little pets. They do what I say, when I say it. It's a very simple arrangement. And you," she leaned in, her breath hot against his ear, "you've been a very naughty boy, watching what isn't yours."

Jake's face flushed with anger, his fists clenching at his sides. Riley saw the muscles in his arms tense, but she held her breath, hoping that Claire's confidence would be enough to keep him in check.

"I don't know what you're talking about," Jake said, his voice strained.

"Oh, come now, Jake," Claire purred, her hand moving down to his chest, her nails lightly scraping against his bare skin. "Don't play coy with me. You know exactly what I'm talking about… I’m willing to make a deal with you. Just tell me, how many girls have you been with?"

Jake's cheeks flushed a deep red, his eyes darting between the three of them. He looked at Claire, then at Riley and Lily, who were both staring at the floor, too embarrassed to meet his gaze. "N-none," he stuttered, the words sticking in his throat.

"Ah, so you're a virgin," Claire said with a knowing smile, her hand continuing to trace lazy patterns on his chest. "Well, that makes this even more interesting." She leaned back, crossing her arms over her chest. "You see, I can change that if you just forget you ever saw anything."

Riley's eyes shot up to meet hers, her heart racing as she realized what Claire was proposing. She felt Lily stiffen beside her, the shock of the situation sinking in. Jake looked at them, his expression a mix of lust and confusion. He knew he had the upper hand, but the offer was too tempting to pass up.

“Not in front of them,” Jake murmured, his voice thick with desire as he nodded towards Riley and Lily.

Claire's smirk grew wider. “Don’t be shy, Jake. You had no problems watching your sister naked last night, and you certainly didn’t mind when she had her mouth full of your cock, thinking it was Lily’s.” Riley’s cheeks burned with humiliation, her eyes shooting up to meet her brother’s horrified gaze. Lily gasped, her hand flying to her mouth in shock.

Jake’s jaw dropped, his eyes darting between the two of them, searching for a hint of truth in Claire’s words. Riley’s eyes filled with tears, and she couldn’t look at him anymore. She had hoped he would never find out about her darkest secret.

“Just lean back and relax, Jake,” Claire said with a smug smile, her eyes glinting with excitement. “I promise you, this will be a morning to remember.” With surprising gentleness, she began to unbutton his shirt, her fingertips dancing over his bare chest as she pushed the fabric aside. Jake's eyes were glued to Riley and Lily, his mind racing with the revelations that had been thrown at him. He couldn’t believe the twisted web his sister had gotten herself into, and yet, his body was betraying him, responding to the sensation of Claire’s touch.

As if sensing his weakness, Claire leaned in closer, her breasts pressing against his bare chest as she whispered in his ear, "You want this, don't you?" Riley watched, her stomach in knots, as her brother's resolve crumbled. He nodded, his eyes never leaving hers.

With a swift, practiced motion, Claire reached down and grabbed the waistband of his pajama pants, pulling them and his underwear down in one fluid movement. Jake's erection sprang free, bobbing slightly in the cool morning air. Riley felt a mix of disgust and arousal at the sight of her brother's nakedness. Lily's hand tightened around her wrist, a silent plea for reassurance.

Claire stepped back, her eyes raking over Jake's body with an appraising gaze. "Now, that's more like it," she said, her voice like honey. "Much better when you're not hiding it." She began to strip out of her own clothes, peeling the dress from her body like a second skin. Her movements were slow and deliberate, as if she were putting on a show for them.

Jake couldn't tear his eyes away from Riley, his mind racing with the implications of what was happening. His penis twitched, a traitorous response to the situation, and he felt his face heat up even further. Riley's eyes met his, a silent apology and plea for understanding in their depths. He knew he should be disgusted, but he couldn't deny the way his body was reacting to the sight of her standing there, naked and vulnerable.

As Claire shed her clothes, she revealed a body that was nothing short of breathtaking. Her skin was a smooth canvas of porcelain. Her breasts were full and firm, her nipples already peaked with anticipation, begging to be touched. Her waist dipped in at just the right place, flaring out into hips that promised a heavenly grip. Her legs were long and toned, leading down to a mound of bare flesh that was as smooth and bald as the day she was born.

Precum beaded at the tip of Jake's cock, a clear sign of his arousal despite his inner turmoil. Claire took notice, a knowing smile playing on her lips as she approached the bed. She moved with the grace of a panther, every step calculated to maximize the impact of her beauty. Riley and Lily watched, their own desires warring with their fear and confusion.

Without a word, Claire positioned herself over Jake, her legs straddling his waist. She hovered for a moment, her hand gently guiding his erection to her wet entrance. The anticipation in the room was electric, a silent current that seemed to charge the very air. Riley's breath hitched as she watched, unable to look away from the scene unfolding before her.

Slowly, inch by inch, Claire lowered herself onto Jake's penis, her eyes never leaving his. He let out a soft gasp as he felt the warm, tight embrace of her body, his hands instinctively reaching up to grasp her hips. Lily's hand squeezed Riley's tighter, both of them sharing the same silent horror and fascination at what was happening.

Riley felt like she should be looking away, that she was intruding on something sacred and private, but she couldn't tear her gaze from the sight before her. Her heart was racing, her mind a whirlwind of thoughts and emotions. “I must be the first person to ever watch their brother lose their virginity,” she thought, her eyes wide with a mix of shock and morbid fascination.

With a final, slow descent, Claire was fully lowered onto Jake. She paused for a moment, her body taut with anticipation. The room was thick with the scent of arousal and the sound of their combined breaths. “Alright, Jake,” she said, her voice a low purr that sent a shiver down Riley’s spine. “Here’s the deal. If you can last over five minutes, you can do whatever you want with Riley and Lily here. But if you don’t, you have to forget everything you saw and leave them alone. Understood?”

Jake nodded, his eyes glazed with lust and determination. Claire began to move, her hips rising and falling in a hypnotic rhythm. She was in complete control, her movements calculated to both maximize her pleasure and prolong Jake’s torment. Riley couldn’t help but watch, her eyes drawn to the spot where their bodies joined. Claire’s pussy was wet, glistening around her brother’s shaft as she rode him. She saw the way his cock disappeared into her, only to re-emerge slick with her juices, and she felt a strange sense of arousal mingling with her fear and anger.

The sight was mesmerizing, and for a brief moment, Riley found herself feeling jealous. She wondered what it would be like to have Jake’s cock inside her, filling her up and stretching her tight. But she quickly pushed the thought away, knowing that it was wrong, that she had no right to feel that way about her own brother. She focused instead on the look of pure pleasure on Claire’s face, the way she threw her head back and moaned as she fucked him.

Lily’s hand was trembling now, and Riley could feel the heat coming off her body. She knew that her friend was just as conflicted as she was. They had both been humiliated and degraded by Claire, but now they were witnessing something so raw and primal that it was hard not to be affected by it.

Riley’s eyes remained glued to the spot where Claire’s pussy swallowed Jake’s cock, watching the way it glistened with every stroke. She felt her own hand move almost of its own accord, sliding down her belly to the soft mound of her sex. She was wet, she realized with a start, her clit begging for attention. Her mind screamed at her to stop, that this was wrong, but her body was betraying her, responding to the explicit show before her.

With trembling fingers, she reached down and began to rub herself, the friction against her clit sending waves of pleasure shooting through her. She couldn’t believe she was doing this, but the sight was too much to ignore. Lily’s grip on her wrist tightened even more, but Riley barely registered it, lost in her own world of conflicting emotions.

Jake’s breathing grew ragged as Claire’s pace increased. His eyes squeezed shut, his teeth gritted as he tried to hold on, to prove himself to the woman who had so easily turned his world upside down. But it was no use; his body had a mind of its own. With a strangled cry, he felt his orgasm building, the pressure in his balls reaching a fever pitch.

In the next moment, he erupted inside her, the hot spurt of his release filling Claire's pussy. Riley watched, her hand frozen on her own clit, as Claire's eyes flashed with triumph. The expression on her brother's face was one of pure ecstasy, his body arching off the bed as he came. Claire's own pleasure was clear on her face, a mix of satisfaction and smugness.

With a final, slow grind against him, Claire lifted herself off, Jake's cum and her own juices spilling out onto his stomach and cock. She leaned over, her breasts brushing against his chest, and whispered in his ear. "Looks like you lost, Jake," she said with a wink.

Jake's erection began to wilt, the reality of what had just happened crashing down on him. He couldn't believe he'd just had sex with someone in front of his sister and her friend. His face was a mask of shock and confusion as he looked up at Claire, his body still trembling from the intensity of his climax.

Claire, however, remained unfazed, a smug smile playing on her lips as she slid off him and began to redress herself. She took her time, enjoying the power she wielded over the two freshmen. Her movements were slow and deliberate, as if she were savoring every moment of their humiliation. Riley couldn't help but watch her, her eyes drawn to the way the fabric clung to Claire's body as she pulled on her dress. She felt a strange mix of anger and admiration for the way Claire could be so utterly shameless.

Finally dressed, Claire turned to Jake, who was still lying on the bed, his cum slowly drying on his stomach. "Now," she said, her voice cold and hard. "You will never, ever, mess with Riley or Lily again. Do you understand?"

Jake nodded, his face a picture of defeat. "Yes, I understand," he murmured.

"Good," Claire said, her voice cold as ice. "Now, I want you to apologize to Riley."

Jake looked up at her, his expression torn between anger and defeat. He knew he was in no position to argue. With a heavy sigh, he turned to Riley, his eyes meeting hers. "I'm sorry," he mumbled.

“Good.” Claire nodded in satisfaction. “Now, Riley, I want you to forgive him.” Her voice was firm, leaving no room for argument.

Riley looked at her brother, his face a mess of confusion and embarrassment. She felt a tumult of emotions, but she knew that fighting Claire’s control would only make things worse. With a heavy heart, she nodded. “Okay, I forgive you,” she murmured.

Claire's smile grew even more smug as she stepped back, watching the siblings with a gleam in her eye. "Good," she said, her voice dripping with satisfaction. "Now, I think you two need to make up properly." Without another word, she grabbed Riley's wrist and pulled her towards the bed, forcing her to stand directly in front of Jake. "Hug it out," she ordered, pushing them closer together.

Jake slowly stood, his eyes never leaving Riley's. The weight of the situation hung heavily in the air as they took a tentative step towards each other. Their bare bodies met in a gentle embrace, skin against skin, and for a moment, it was like nothing else in the world existed. The sensation was overwhelming, a mix of warmth and awkwardness that only siblings could understand. Jake's arms wrapped around her waist, his hands resting just above her ass, his fingers brushing against the soft curve of her hips.

"Are you okay?" he whispered into her ear, his breath hot against her neck. Riley nodded, her eyes closing as she leaned into him, feeling the comfort of his touch. Despite everything that had happened, she knew that deep down, he was still her brother, and she still loved him.

As they held each other, she felt his erection growing again, pressing against her belly. The sensation sent a jolt through her, a mix of horror and excitement. She knew she couldn’t let this continue, not with Lily watching, not with Claire's wicked grin plastered on her face. Riley stepped back, breaking the embrace. Jake's cheeks reddened, his gaze dropping to the floor.

“Well, Jake… I hope you’ve enjoyed yourself,” Claire said with a wicked glint in her eye. “Now, it’s time for Riley and Lily to go back to her room. We wouldn’t want to keep them from their final task, would we?” She turned to the two freshmen, her expression unyielding.

With that, Claire turned and sauntered out of the room, leaving the door open behind her. Riley and Lily hurriedly followed, their naked forms moving swiftly across the floor. Jake's eyes couldn't help but linger on their retreating figures, especially their bare butts bouncing slightly with each step they took. He watched, his cock fully hardening again as the sight of their nudity filled his vision. He felt a mix of guilt and arousal, his mind reeling from the events that had just unfolded.

[Emily]

New part should be up sometime this weekend

It’s almost done, just debating on if it is too inappropriate or if I should tone some things down on it.

I hope you all are enjoying reading this as much as I’m enjoying writing it. Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated