Four sisters, lots of peeping and showing

[PeepingMax69]

Exposing Myself
Keep in mind this was about 15 years ago so I'm filling some gaps especially with the conversation.

So I don't know if our parents sensed something or maybe just realized we were all at a curious age but shortly after Mary and I had our Dance game/wrestling match. They had rule that none of girls should be in my room with the door closed. The rule made me nervous because I thought Mary had said something so we didn't hang out for a couple weeks really.

But like many of the rules they would later put in place, our parents basically just forgot. (This was something my step-dad did constantly, make a new rule yell at everyone, punish you, then forget). So one afternoon Mary is back in my room playing Just Dance. She came in and asked to play, I said sure and she closed the door. I was nervous about that but didn't say anything.

She was dressed a little more modestly still tshirt and shorts but nothing that was giving me a view. I was watching her and decided I wanted to wrestle some more. I went to the bathroom first, trying to sneak so no one realized Mary was in my room and took my underwear and wore just my gym shorts. I went back to my room, heart racing. I watched her ay another couple songs then grabbed her around the waist.

We wrestled on the bed, I had to keep telling her to be quiet, she was laughing and giggling, so we didn't get caught. It quickly just turned into me dry humping her, she stopped and looked me in the eye and said: "I can feel your thing against me."

"Oh sorry."

"It's okay, I know boys get stiff."

"How do you know that?"

She shrugged, "Boys at school."

"Oh."

"Can I see it?"

"I don't know, your dad might get mad." I got really scared at this point but didn't do anything

"It's okay just be quick, we'll hear them coming."

"Okay." I say on my bed and still nervously looking at my door I pushed my shorts down just enough to take my penis out. I had some hair at the time but not much. My heart was racing. She looked at it and reached out to barely touch the head and giggled. I think I was in shock. After a minute she said: "You can cover up." I wanted to ask to see hers but my brain was fog. "We can wrestle more." So we went back and I awkwardly started humping her again. She seemed to get into, I don't remember how ling we did before my mom came down the hall and we hopped apart. She called us to dinner and didn't say anything about my closed door.


I'm trying to remember and fill in as much detail as I can. Let me know if you have questions because I may be missing key parts or context.

[NickTwisp]

Great story! It must have been a kind of naughty/exciting feeling when you pulled down your shorts. I wonder if your bio sister or the other two step-sisters had any inkling of what was going on between you & Mary?

At that age (12-13) I could and did have intense dry orgasms. Humping anything would have caused this let alone a real girl. Did you masturbate later on that day thinking of what had occurred with Mary?

[PeepingMax69]

Great story! It must have been a kind of naughty/exciting feeling when you pulled down your shorts. I wonder if your bio sister or the other two step-sisters had any inkling of what was going on between you & Mary?

At that age (12-13) I could and did have intense dry orgasms. Humping anything would have caused this let alone a real girl. Did you masturbate later on that day thinking of what had occurred with Mary?

I don't think anyone had any idea of what we did, but as the other two got older we played similar games.

I got off as soon as I could thinking about it later. I was already a frequent masturbator before my mom got married. living with those girls I couldn't stop myself

[Dario_me]

Exposing Myself
She shrugged, "Boys at school."

I wanted to ask to see hers but my brain was fog.

It seems this wasn't the first time Mary had been in a situation like this, which is why she was less shocked than you. Do you think she would have shown up if there had been enough time?
Even when my cousin showed me her private parts, I remember how foggy my mind was and how I didn't understand anything.

[TONI]

I think she's seen a dick before. She just wanted to see yours. Because it seems from her reaction that this is not a reaction for someone who is seeing a dick for the first time.

[PeepingMax69]

Exposing Myself
She shrugged, "Boys at school."

I wanted to ask to see hers but my brain was fog.

It seems this wasn't the first time Mary had been in a situation like this, which is why she was less shocked than you. Do you think she would have shown up if there had been enough time?
Even when my cousin showed me her private parts, I remember how foggy my mind was and how I didn't understand anything.

I think she would have shown me, she did later (I'll get there). Yeah I do wish I wasn't so shaken up though to have asked.

I think she's seen a dick before. She just wanted to see yours. Because it seems from her reaction that this is not a reaction for someone who is seeing a dick for the first time.

Yes, Dario made same comment, you're both right. I didn't know then that she had seen a few before, but as we grew up I learned that Mary had always been boy crazy and had gotten attention from boys (and older guys) before. I was just a new boy close to her.

[PeepingMax69]

The Pool
So after showing off for Mary, we had a couple more moments where I saw up her shorts in my room (just glimpsing her lips) but then the No Door Closed rule was getting enforced again and they got stricter on putting up your laundry so Kacey wasn't changing in laundry room nearly as often.

I'm skipping some stuff that happened with my step dad, he was very inconsistent but also super strict and moody so all of us received spankings (sometimes bare) but never in front of each other, though I managed to spy a couple times and that story. Anyway, my point is I'm skipping those stories about me for here because they don't involve my sisters so idk if anyone would want to read those.

So the Pool. A few months after the wedding it's summer and my step dad opens the pool. He and my mom had a VERY loud and long argument over whether the girls could get bikinis. Step-dad was very against and Anna had been wearing them forever. Well the compromise was bikinis at home and one pieces in public or the beach.

Girls go off one day and shop and come home. Kacey was very shy and wouldn't show her new two piece but Mary of course did and it was a sunflower print, pretty modest overall but still made me very hard and uncomfortable especially since Step Dad was there too. Daisy and Anna showed off theirs and the only thing I remember noticing about them was that Anna's barely covered her butt.

Next day we're in the pool, Kacey wore here plain one piece which still showed her curves great. We just all played and goofed off. Step dad got in and out, my mom didn't get in just tanned. And every so often Mary would "accidentally" bump into me and laugh if she felt me hard.

After awhile the parents went inside Anna and Daisy went to play on the swings and I was left with Kacey and Mary. Suddenly felt very awkward. I asked Kacey why she didn't wear her new suit and Mary started teasing her. They started arguing and I remember
Mary: I don't why you care you don't have anything to cover up
Kacey: More than you, at least I'm not flat
Mary: She wears two bras because her nipples are so big (which as far as I knew wasn't true I think that happened when they were younger because I'd watched kacey change)
Kacey: Shut up I don't. At least I don't show everyone my pussy. She showed her whole class her pussy
Mary: I didn't!
Then Kacey yanked Mary's bottoms down. Mary froze and I thinking quick went underwater and got my first close look. Wasn't like a clear view but she didn't cover up.

When she did pull her bottoms up Kacey left and we just stayed there awkwardly. I was trying to get courage to say anything when Anna and Daisy came back.

[NickTwisp]

Seems like Mary was in no particular rush to pull the lower part of her swimsuit back up. Likely she knew you went underwater & got somewhat of a look.

[Freesub]

Sounds like she was definitely wanting you to see it, or else she would have tried to cover up.

[PeepingMax69]

Seems like Mary was in no particular rush to pull the lower part of her swimsuit back up. Likely she knew you went underwater & got somewhat of a look.

She knew I went under and yeah didn't fight that hard or rush to get it up