Bluff Called on stripping game

[justcantgetitup]

This happened during the school summer holidays when I was house sitting for a relative who had two daughters. I had just turned 15 and they were 10 and 8 respectively. My duties ran from when the mother left for her part time job in the morning, until her return in mid afternoon.

The girls had wanted to rope me into a childish card game with them and wouldn't take no for an answer, while I wanted them to leave me alone so I could listen to the England Cricket commentary on the radio. Close to losing my patience, I said "OK, let's play strip jack naked. It's like strip jack except we're playing for our clothes and it goes on until someone's got nothing on." expecting that they'd be grossed out and leave me alone. To my horror, they went for it. I resolved that when one of them lost their last but one item, they'd get cold feet and I could call the game off. However there was no such concession for me when things went wrong and I lost my last but one item while they still had 3 each. "KNICKERS OFF!!" they called. It actually seemed a better offer than being left in my cheap tighty whities that they'd see my pubes through. My last item was an elasticated football shirt that I could stretch to cover my modesty but I'm sure the end of my penis showed briefly, though they never said if it did. (This shirt would let me down, big league, the following summer but that's another story.)

So the dilemma, was it more humiliating to get naked in front of them or lose credibility by stopping the game? I carried on and 10 went down to singlet and panties, then lost the next game too. 8 shouted "KNICKERS OFF! and 10 refused. Was this the off ramp for me? I told 10 "Just get your vest off then, you might not need to get your knickers off anyway if I lose the next game! " 10 was spooked now so I called the game off. 8 tried to call me a scaredy cat but I said "Look! I've GOT my knickers off! You could've had me walking round with nothing on until your Mom comes home but you won't play fair! Let's just forget this ever happened!" So with that fit of pretend annoyance, I folded my cards, got dressed and breathed a huge sigh of relief.

I thought nothing of the incident again until 8 years later when the girl's parents went on a long trip abroad, leaving them in the care of my parents. The night before they left, their Mom cornered me with a serious look on her face and said. "DON'T touch my daughters while I'm away! PLEASE!" I stammered back "Of course not! What are you talking about? Why would I?" "Just.Promise.Me." came the reply. Of course I did promise but she never said why she was doing this to me.

Some days later, I wondered if she'd heard tales of the strip game, my peeping penis and me being annoyed when 10 wouldn't take off her underwear all those years ago. I wish to God I'd just kept my cool and never suggested the stupid game in the first place, but with hindsight I can't help wondering if having got into that predicament, I should have just thrown the game when I got down to my shirt and greeted the Mom naked on her return, explaining it away as a childish prank to get it sorted then, swapping short term embarrassment for the reputational damage I suspect I have suffered within the family.

[tim409]

In all fairness, you did not touch the girls but I was wishing they were better at the game and that they would have gotten you naked. Still good story and I do hope they did peek at your penis.

[Freesub]

Did either of them hesitate at all to show you their panties? Or was it just being naked that scared them?

Also, did you call the game off before 10 took her vest off? Or was it after another round afterwards?

[Robert Brooks]

Fantastic story, Justcantgetitup! Absolutely loved it
I love your description of your 'cheap tighty-whities' and how the girls called them knickers! Were they just plain, unbranded supermarket type pants? Or even Y-fronts? Very embarrassing to be seen in at 15 by younger girls!!

[justcantgetitup]

In all fairness, you did not touch the girls but I was wishing they were better at the game and that they would have gotten you naked. Still good story and I do hope they did peek at your penis.

Thanks for your comments. I was very lucky with a few of the hands and came within a pubic hair's width of losing. I think they MUST have seen the first inch of my penis because when I first took off my tight underpants there was a rush of blood to my groin causing a brief semi that poked through the bottom of my shirt before quickly shrinking again.

[tim409]

In all fairness, you did not touch the girls but I was wishing they were better at the game and that they would have gotten you naked. Still good story and I do hope they did peek at your penis.

Thanks for your comments. I was very lucky with a few of the hands and came within a pubic hair's width of losing. I think they MUST have seen the first inch of my penis because when I first took off my tight underpants there was a rush of blood to my groin causing a brief semi that poked through the bottom of my shirt before quickly shrinking again.

Did you ever find out why the mom was so upset? In reality it would be good for young girls to see their first mature male genitals in a safe setting than on the streets. 10 and 8 y/o girls are at the perfect age to see actual mature male genitals in a safe place.

[justcantgetitup]

Did either of them hesitate at all to show you their panties? Or was it just being naked that scared them?

Also, did you call the game off before 10 took her vest off? Or was it after another round afterwards?

Thanks for reading and thanks for your questions. I never saw 8's panties, she still had 3 items on when the game ended so her panties were hidden under her skirt. 10 looked a little self conscious but didn't hesitate to whip her skirt off.

Sorry for not making the second point clear. I was a bit conscious of putting too much detail into my first post. When 10 lost the hand which would've taken her down to one item, she not only refused to take her panties off when 8 told her to, but when I said to take her vest off instead, she got spooked, made an arm-bra and put her other hand in front of her panties, making it pretty obvious she wasn't taking anything else off. That was when I stopped the game.

I don't know why she was suddenly spooked because we never talked about it. Maybe she was scared of getting naked. Maybe it was seeing my peeping penis that freaked her out.

[justcantgetitup]

Fantastic story, Justcantgetitup! Absolutely loved it
I love your description of your 'cheap tighty-whities' and how the girls called them knickers! Were they just plain, unbranded supermarket type pants? Or even Y-fronts? Very embarrassing to be seen in at 15 by younger girls!!

Thanks for your kind words and I'm glad you liked the story.

They were indeed supermarket Y-fronts at the end of their life. My Mom decided that I was grown up enough to have navy blue Y-fronts with sky blue piping next time.

[justcantgetitup]

In all fairness, you did not touch the girls but I was wishing they were better at the game and that they would have gotten you naked. Still good story and I do hope they did peek at your penis.

Thanks for your comments. I was very lucky with a few of the hands and came within a pubic hair's width of losing. I think they MUST have seen the first inch of my penis because when I first took off my tight underpants there was a rush of blood to my groin causing a brief semi that poked through the bottom of my shirt before quickly shrinking again.

Did you ever find out why the mom was so upset? In reality it would be good for young girls to see their first mature male genitals in a safe setting than on the streets. 10 and 8 y/o girls are at the perfect age to see actual mature male genitals in a safe place.

No, I never did find out for certain. We're not a family that talks things out. My best guess is that it was ultimately an issue of trust. The Mom was always a stickler for having a debrief of what we'd been doing whilst she was away and I omitted the strip game from my report out of embarrassment. Then the girls must have told her what happened later on and she concluded that I'd been up to no good and had tried to keep it quiet. I was never asked for my version of events. Maybe as far as she was concerned, I blew my chance to come clean on the day.

[tim409]

No, I never did find out for certain. We're not a family that talks things out. My best guess is that it was ultimately an issue of trust. The Mom was always a stickler for having a debrief of what we'd been doing whilst she was away and I omitted the strip game from my report out of embarrassment. Then the girls must have told her what happened later on and she concluded that I'd been up to no good and had tried to keep it quiet. I was never asked for my version of events. Maybe as far as she was concerned, I blew my chance to come clean on the day.

I wonder that if you told her that you planned on letting the girls win so they would see their first mature penis and testicles in a SAFE setting if it would have made a difference?